During the Denver Indianapolis game, while showing Adam Vinatieri and Peyton Manning, Phil Simms says, "now htere are two of the clutchest players ever". What!? Are you kidding me!? Peyton Manning clutch!? He's about as clutch as A-Rod and Karl Malone. Peyton is the anti-clutch.
In high school he started for 3 years and only lost 5 games - no state championships. He was one of the most prolific college quarterbacks ever - no national championships, no wins against rival U of F. And we all know how many times he's crapped his pants in big games in the NFL.
So if by clutch Phil meant throwing three 4th quarter touchdowns when already ahead by 24 in week 7. Then yes he is one of the clutchest ever.