Recommended Posts
![[:/] [:/]](/uploads/emoticons/dry.png)
Keepin' it safe...
Ed
We need mandatory canopy survival training. Very bad statistics, many excellent coaches available to make a positive effect. Still these services are optional.
But we don't need mandatory wingsuit instruction. Damn near perfect record in the skydiving environment, very few skilled at the pay me a days wages for what would be the experience of a 10,000- 7,000- 5,000 or even 2,000 jumps in that exact discipline kind of instruction. How many people have even 2,000 wingsuit jumps.... not very many! Some instructors have less than a hundred jumps in wingsuits. Less than two hours in freefall with a wingsuit and now they want to be regarded as some kind of regional expert on wingsuit flight and its instruction?
What would you say to a skilled craftsman that was charging you for their services when he told you that he has been doing this for two hours? How about a lawyer with that much court time? A dentist? A doctor, a brainsurgeon? Expert my ass! I AIN'T PAYING YOU jack is what you would say.
You name them: Dave brown, Clint Clauson, Dan BC. ( insert famous name here ) they all have many , many thousands of jumps in their fields and can say they deserve the fees that their level or quality of instruction should get them. And their services are STILL optional, you can do it yourself through the school of the 10,000 jumps and hard knocks.
Plus its just not legislation its still optional.
tomorrow is the weekend.
sweeeettt !!!
Keeping it real 22x7
TomAiello 26
Can small DZ's go on with informal mentoring programs, while large DZ's have more formalized instruction? Why not? Would students start going out to the small DZ's to learn?
In BASE, we've relatively recently had some wacko just start offering the formal instruction for free. Is this the equivalent of free FFC's? What about free coaching?
I dunno. I obviously have a strong bias in favor of the free "pay back the sport later" type of mentoring in most things, and I believe I've put my money where my mouth is quite strongly on that issue.
But I'm wondering if the two types can't coexist?
Tom@SnakeRiverBASE.com
SnakeRiverBASE.com
If I chose my "real job" to be telemarketing would you be forced to float me a sale?
If I chose my real job to be the guy in the mens bathroom with an array of colognes and linen towels, would you be compelled to drop a few coin in my tray because a chose to make that my "real" job?
If I need an AFF instructor or tandem master, then yes I need to pay for that rated individual's organizational fees. Few ways around that . Wingsuiting instruction isn't a job. And there is is less than a handful of individuals that are true experts at it!
When people start to realise we are all just a bunch of apprentices this forum will have a much better flow.
QuoteWe need mandatory canopy survival training.
We wouldn't need it if we jumped the parachutes as we did before you were even jumping.
QuoteVery bad statistics, many excellent coaches available to make a positive effect. Still these services are optional.
Exactly, optional.

QuoteBut we don't need mandatory wingsuit instruction.
Where did you here anyone say we did?
Though thourgh and correct instruction is a wise option

QuoteLess than two hours in freefall with a wingsuit and now they want to be regarded as some kind of regional expert on wingsuit flight and its instruction?
And who would this be?
QuoteWhat would you say to a skilled craftsman that was charging you for their services when he told you that he has been doing this for two hours? How about a lawyer with that much court time? A dentist? A doctor, a brainsurgeon? Expert my ass! I AIN'T PAYING YOU jack is what you would say.
True, but thats my option.
After learning to jumpmaster yourself just about everything else in skydiving is optional.

Keppin it safe!
Ed
www.PrecisionSkydiving.com
But I'm wondering if the two types can't coexist?
This individual isn't Wacko unles the course is truelly unsafe and wacky, I doubt it is.
I believe that both forms can ( and must, for the time being ) coexist. For the simple reason of accesability. Lack of uniformity in manufacturer recommendations. And lack of governing body intervention or involvement . The last sentence may not apply to all governing bodies.
Yet this isn't good enough for some people. Its easy to say somebody else's program is unsafe but its damn hard to prove because of very exceptable( not perfect) historic incedent data.
One side claims the other " outside the program" methods are unsafe. Factions outside this team claim this as a marketing ploys and not a safety concern. Which BTW is easier to prove considering we have a safe and steady healthy growth in wingsuiters coming newly trained from both areas. Yet its an exceptable practice for this faction to qualify low experience " instructors". In some cases very low in wingsuiting experience. Not really a sign of a "safety driven" protocal but more of a marketing pyramid sceme.
QuoteIf I chose my "real job" to be telemarketing would you be forced to float me a sale?
Nope. That would be my option to hang up.

QuoteIf I chose my real job to be the guy in the mens bathroom with an array of colognes and linen towels, would you be compelled to drop a few coin in my tray because a chose to make that my "real" job?
Now that depends on how good you shined my shoes? Then I'd probably tip you heavy for having to hang in the bathroom.

QuoteIf I need an AFF instructor or tandem master, then yes I need to pay for that rated individual's organizational fees.
But then why wouldnt you just rent a C182 and borrow a rig, remove the door and jump?
It would probably take you sometime, but you eventually get it right.
QuoteWingsuiting instruction isn't a job.
And you probably think being a packer isn't either ....

QuoteAnd there is is less than a handful of individuals that are true experts at it!
Very true.

QuoteWhen people start to realise we are all just a bunch of apprentices this forum will have a much better flow.
Who are you an apprentice to Glen?
Keepin' it safe!
Ed
www.PrecisionSkydiving.com
QuoteI started on military rounds, static line then on to FF. Twenty years ago. I don't care what they had before I started jumping. What I had when I started wasn't Good enough then. I like what I jump now. More importantly I love the strides that the manufacturers work hard to make and wouldn't go retro for anything.... unless the aircraft is on fire. BTW I have more injuries from back then than I do now ( zero from the now era).
QuoteLess than two hours in freefall with a wingsuit and now they want to be regarded as some kind of regional expert on wingsuit flight and its instruction?
And who would this be?Quote
I'll even be generous and go Five hours. The
who would be most as in most of the instructor cadre ( I know you personnaly have quite a bit more- plus, you know others that I refer to are not as fortunate as you ) Definatly not the guy that got the rating without even owning his own suit. And not anybody that only does wingsuits on rare occasion.
It would probably take you sometime, but you eventually get it right.
Quote
Few ways around this. None that are smart involve bypassing instruction. I've allready conceded this ED
But when it comes to wingsuit flight , there are many ways to get there. TOO many ways and you just can't seem to concede this ED.QuoteWingsuiting instruction isn't a job.
And you probably think being a packer isn't either ....![]()
Not only is it a job its one of the hardest jobs on the DZ you earn every dollar. When it comes to packing for a living some people are hacks and others masters at their crafts with incomes that reflect this.
But their services are again optional to the individual skydiver, who could....... should learn to pack their own gear.QuoteWhen people start to realise we are all just a bunch of apprentices this forum will have a much better flow.
Who are you an apprentice to Glen?
Just about everybody I fly with even if I'm teaching them something I'm usually learning something in the process...... And I never consider myself as their resident regional expert of the day.
Kdsosso 0
Since you have asked for opinions, I will offer mine:
Although I have been in the sport for a short time and have made few wingsuit jumps (I need a suit to make more!) I find your posts in general to be more argumentative rather than insightful and thought provoking.
You stated:
----------------------------------------------------------
The problem is, wingsuiting skipped a step. RW isn't
dead, and freeflying isn't overrun with cocksuckers.
People are trying to take wingsuiting straight from
the 'small group of pioneers' stage, to the world
record/skill camp/skygod/money stage right away,
without going through the building stage. They want to
----------------------------------------------------------
HUH? I think that everyones ability is different and their are some people that have the ability to fly a suit to the record/skill camp/skygod/money stage..I have seen some of them fly and most are have sevral thousands of jumps in different disciplines and know how to fly well. So not sure where you were going with this. I really don't get it

I certainly would not have been comfortable flying a suit without being coached by a BMI and I wouldn't recommend anyone flying a suit without proper training (my opinion)and I am willing and able to pay $$ for this service. I do expect them to be BMI's and I expect them to want to be paid for this service.
My question to you is : Is anything okay? You seem very upset in you posts and almost like you are trying to stir the pot..however if you've notice the more experienced instructors show class when responding to the posts that I feel are not here to evoke change or to inspire the interchanging of ideas, but are only posted here to argue and "seem" controversial.
I challenge you to write posts that contribute to the true spirit of this forum rather than create havoc and separation between people
![[:/] [:/]](/uploads/emoticons/dry.png)
It's all about being safe and having fun!

If I misunderstood all your posts, then I truly apologize.

-A new wingsuit flyer
QuoteEloy, with a structured school and a ban on 'freelance mentoring'.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Quote
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I have not heard of this "ban" - was this instilled by the BMIs pissed about the free mentoring or by the DZ.
This in no way has anything to do with the BMIs at Eloy or anywhere for that matter. If you want to peddle your services, sell your t-shirts, pack chutes, sell coffee, etc you need to go through the DZ. SDA and many other DZ's do not allow people to willy nilly set up shop and sell products or services without their consent. Be it the Freefly guy selling coaching or a guy selling gear out of the trunk of his car, if you do it without the DZ's approval you're probably going to be told to stop or shown the road.
Some people dream about flying, I live my dream
SKYMONKEY PUBLISHING
riggerrob 643
I'll leap into this argument!
I may not be a wingsuit instructor - heck! I only have a half-dozen wingsuit dives - but my armpits ... er .... opinions stink as much as the next guy's.
You guys missed the point about the steep learning curve during the first few wingsuit dives.
A little instruction can vastly improve that learning curve.
As to whether wingsuit instruction should be free .... I will give free wingsuit instruction as soon as someone sweeps out my loft for free, mows the grass for free, repacks reserves for free, patches my jumpsuit for free, packs my tandems for free, feeds me for free, refuels my airplane for free, etc.
riggerrob 643
and cool starts up. a few crazies start doing it. For
a while, it's just a fringe thing, then others start
doing it. People who are displeased with the current
'big thing' start jumping in. It gets more and more
popular, and pretty soon, it's a discipline. All the
'big thing' guys criticize it, but it grows, because
it's the way to have fun, with your friends, instead
of getting your ass chewed for 'ruining someone's
skydive'. And the new thing grows and grows, and it
becomes the popular, big thing, that everyone wants to
do. And then comes the bullshit. The world records.
The tunnel camps. The skill camps. Paid coaching.
Factory sponsorships. Money to be made. And skygods
with thousands of jumps, chewing everyone's ass for
ruining their skydive. And that's when the next new
thing starts up, and the cycle repeats. This happened
with Style and Acc to RW, RW to Freefly, and it was
going to happen with Freefly to wingsuiting.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
The first part is correct about cycles.
However, I am hoping that wingsuiting turns into a "new thrill" to keep skydivers interested when they reach the 3 year/300 jump burn-out phase.
Quoteand Eloy, with a structured school and a ban on 'freelance mentoring'.
You sir are exhagerating. We do not have a "ban" as you call it. We do however believe in the interest of safety for all our patrons.
As such, we chose to use qualified instructors. If they do not have a BMI then a decision is based on case by case basis.
If someone has displayed poor decision making in the past (such as flying into jump run) then you are correct they won't be taking up first flights here.
QuoteSomeone ought to be able to tally ws jumps/week at these two dz
We do. We also know exactly how many flights for skills camps and boogies.
QuoteOkay!
I'll leap into this argument!
You guys missed the point about the steep learning curve during the first few wingsuit dives.
A little instruction can vastly improve that learning curve.
As to whether wingsuit instruction should be free .... I will give free wingsuit instruction as soon as someone sweeps out my loft for free, mows the grass for free, repacks reserves for free, patches my jumpsuit for free, packs my tandems for free, feeds me for free, refuels my airplane for free, etc.
I agree with getting a little instruction. Its always better not to stumble along in a vacuum. But the first jump course is simply that one jump, about a minute of flight time. This does very little for subsequent jump learning curve. meanwhile I find that the guys that are "giving back" to the sport spend the whole day and are on those subsequent jumps helping with that learning curve. Few " this is what I do for living" types could afford to spend the whole rest of the day and be there on follow up jumps for free. Because the mentors are trying to develope a safe, local flock culture, one could almost describe it as an ongoing program.
Don't get me wrong. Everybodys time is worth something. Nobody should feel they have to give it away. If there are costs in travel, equiptment, and time spent. Then it is fair to get a return. I don't expect anyone to work for free.
I see plenty of organizers in all disciplines RW,FF and CReW is a supreme example, donating time and energy. Working very hard in scheduling logistics, cordination and yes even training to some degree. Sometimes their compensation is a slot covered and sometimes its nothing more than a groovy time with a bunch of locals that they wish to be an ongoing thing.
Yes most of the bigger DZ have consession "agreements" on all of the services provided and who is allowed as part of those consessions. I would be interested to hear the sentiment to someone doing free organizing , training & coaching there considering the fact that there is a wingsuit school. How an exception would be provided for?
Is a wingsuit instructor readily available?
No "giant" DZ here Bro.
We do have a turbine running most of the time, but have been know to fly the C206 when it's slow.
Coaching jumps are an option program.
If you have over 500 jumps you can take the FJC, rent suit and jump by yourself.
If you have under 500 jumps, I suggest one coach jump without the wingsuit and then one wingsuit coach jump.
Most see more professionalism in someone that has a "school" set up these days and are willing to pay for it IMO.
Thats becuse it's not your real job.
I too have jumped at a small C182 DZ that was that way.
You have never been here so thats not a fare comment is it?
True, they aren't very hard to fly, but not teaching what to do when things go wrong can be ugly.
Keepin' it safe...
Ed
www.PrecisionSkydiving.com
Share this post
Link to post
Share on other sites