0
ChasingBlueSky

A thought for Newbies Giving Advice

Recommended Posts

Quote



Main Entry: per·spi·ca·cious
Pronunciation: "p&r-sp&-'kA-sh&s
Function: adjective
Etymology: Latin perspicac-, perspicax, from perspicere
Date: 1640
: of acute mental vision or discernment : KEEN
synonym see SHREWD
- per·spi·ca·cious·ly adverb
- per·spi·ca·cious·ness noun
- per·spi·cac·i·ty /-'ka-s&-tE/ noun




:)
Incidently, the trade name "Perspex" is derived from the noun.

You have a great dictionary. Mine's much simpler, and gives no history.

t
It's the year of the Pig.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote



Tonto i agree with what you are saying, but re: the "do nothing if they are more experienced than you" comment, is this really what you want us new guys to do?



The question was "Say I see someone doing something very dangerous."

This indicates and act, rather than an ommision. Yes. By all means, if you see something you know to be wrong point that out. I mentioned specifics. Please don't hold me to what I never said.

t
It's the year of the Pig.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I am a newbie..only 8 months in the sport alittle under 200 jumps but i feel that my experienced already saved some of my friends the other day from doing something stupid.

As I was going to the boarding area with my teamate for collegiate nationals i saw three other kids from my college planning a dive. I asked them what they attempted. One kid (alittle over 100 jumps) said that he is getting his sitfly down well and can stand, so he was going to do a hybrid and hang under neath kid number two (50 jumps) and kid number 3 (about 200 jumps but not current at all). I told them that I didnt want to ruin their fun but I didnt think the situation was very safe. I thought that kid number one with the 100 jumps would prob end up corking if he even was able to hang underthem for alittle. I warned one of the kids who was suppose to be on their belly and said you might get kicked in the face or comlpetely taken out if he corks. They unded up decided then just to do a 3way and sure enough i watche dtheir exit, the second they jumped our the door the whole dive fell apart and they couldnt even stay with each other on their bellies.

Now being a newbie, and being as frequent to the dropzone as I am (asking a million questions, observing, getting chewed out for making wrong decisions (hasnt happened since jump 30!)) I feel I was right in this case to say something. I felt that it was my obligation. I knew of a hazard and I think if there are other kids out there in my situation that bite their tuonge beacuse some people will say they are trying to show off or think they know so much is a joke, because bad things can happen.

Another jump of mine I was jumping with someone who had 1,000's of jumps. We were goign to be 2nd out the door following a couple who was attempting head down together (we were sitflying, one f my coach jumps). At 45 jumps, I asked my coach if it would be smart the way we exited and did our movemens in the air because he would be backsliding and id be practicing foward movement right into where this couple was practicing to learn headdown. Sure enuogh he agreeded with me and did think it would be smarter to switch spots on exit so we wouldnt be going into their airspace.

Whenver it comes to people I dont know, or people i know that have more experience then me, I will ask someone their advice. My friend did it the other day. My friend was under canopy and some guy was messing around with him with only 100 jumps (it was actually the same kid who wanted to do the hybrid and hang underneath the two belly flyers, and actually the same jump). They got realy close to each other and the kid changed his pull altitude from 3,500 to almost 5,000 and then spiriled down to my friend and considered to try to perform some CRW moves. Well when he got on the ground he was mad but didnt feel it was his place to say anything (he has the same amount of jumps as me) and went to one of the packers who was packin for him and explained the sitaution. The packer then talked to the kid and after he denied everything finally listened.

So for all the newbies out there, I guess what this really long post is trying to say is that if you see something you think is wrong, say something. Ask, tell someone u know with more experience with you. You may be wrong and may find out why you are wrong too (which can be great advice too). But whatever, dont hold your tounge and feel that cause u may be a 100 jump wonder doesnt mean you dont know sh*t about what you are doing. You may not know more then everyone else on the plane, but sometimes you may just be right.

Well thats my 2 cents. Take it as you will.

"Airborne all the way"
EL Cantador Rodriguez

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

im talking about if a new guy spots someone more experienced who might have forgotten something like a chest strap or something.


If the experienced person is me and you see something that doesn't look right on my gear PLEASE tell me. If you're wrong I'll thank you for giving a shit and letting me know; if you're right you may have saved my life and believe me I'll thank you for it.

That's not the issue here.

Some people would say I have a lot of experience in this sport. I guess I do, but in limited areas. I know very little about CRW, freeflying or BASE so it's gonna be pretty rare to see one of my posts in one of those forums. If I do post there it will be because I have a question about the discipline and I know there are people with a lot of experience posting there who can give me the "right answers." Although I have a rigger's ticket I have very little technical rigging knowledge, so it is again very rare for me to chime in on a thread discussing hands on rigging or equipment design theory.

I've done a few wingsuit jumps, enough to know it's awesome anyway, but again I won't be chiming in on many threads in the wingsuit forum until I've done a LOT more jumps on my suit - even if I know the "right answer" to the question because I've read what those experienced folks have to say about it.

I do have quite a bit of knowledge about new and used gear and equipment and the process of buying and selling it. Those are the threads I'm most likely to give advice in. Even with years of gear sales experience I rarely give advice on video and camera related gear questions because camera-related gear is my weak area - I can get you what you want but you're far better off determining what you want by talking with people who actually fly cameras.

There are people posting here who haven't been in the sport for a year, have 100-ish jumps total and yet they're chiming in with "advice" or opinions on subjects covering the complete scope of the sport. You'll see them posting in nearly every forum here. An example would be a recent thread where the question was "is this person ready to go to a crossbraced canopy?" and someone with 50 jumps chimes in - sorry, but at 50 jumps, if you haven't been hanging around swoopers or selling gear for awhile (ie more than a year or so) you do NOT have the knowledge on that particular subject yet to even comment. Another example would be the "my first canopy was loaded at 1.3, I have 100 jumps and I haven't hurt myself yet so you won't either, go ahead and buy it" comment when someone is asking about downsizing.

It's not a race to see who can post an answer first when a new thread comes up. If you don't have a lot of experience with the subject - regardless of how many jumps you have total - resist the urge to "share your knowledge" or pass along your opinion and let someone who does have experience in that area answer the question.

What I'm saying next doesn't apply just to those with under XXX jumps or X years in the sport - it applies to everyone. We've got some people posting here who are extremely experienced in different areas of the sport. Take advantage of them, they love it. Listen more than you talk in the topical forums. Ask questions, and ask for clarification of things they say that you might not understand. But leave the advice giving, opinions and arguments for subjects you know forwards and backwards; for some of us that may mean only posting "advice" in Talkback, Intros and Women's and there's nothing wrong with that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I honestly believe that a newbie that pays attention here can give better advice than a lot of instructors I've met. I've been given some WRONG information from at least one tandem instructor. I've heard bullshit that makes no sense from at least one rigger. And I can think of at least one incident posted on dz.com that relates directly to a newbie taking advice from a very experienced jumper (the type that SHOULD be giving advice).

I've read a lot more posts on here from experienced jumpers complaining about newbies giving advice than I've seen posts by newbies giving advice. And I don't think the danger is nearly as bad as it's made out. Newbies are handing out information to newbies at dropzones all the time. Is it only worse here because it's being broadcast to the world?

I think there's plenty of advice that a new jumper can share. There is other advice that they shouldn't touch with a ten foot pole. I just don't see a lot of newbies giving direct wingloading advice to anyone (as in, "you'll be able to handle a 120 canopy, don't worry about it"). And anyone that takes advice like that from ANY stranger should be smacked (if the ground hasn't already done it).

I'm willing to bet there are a lot of jumpers buying larger canopies than they would have if they didn't read dropzone.com. I've been told by numerous people (not on here) that the Sabre2 135 I bought it too big for me, and I was even told by a tandem instructor that I shouldn't have upsized my reserve to a 143 because a 120 reserve was probably too big for me already.

So I agree that there is advice newbies shouldn't be giving, but I believe there's plenty of advice they can give, and it's everyone's responsibility to get a second opinion from someone you trust before you go out and do something stupid.

Dave

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
For ALL of you. . .

Here is a bit of advice from a "Newbie". . .I am a true newbie. . .I have 7 jumps. . .I still have to do my AFF level 7 and 8, then I have to make COUNTLESS numbers of jumps to get anywhere near some of you.

When you make a BLANKET statement such as "your a newbie, don't give advice." You negate everything we have learned up to this point. Now mind you, I have NEVER given advice on this board and when I have an opinion on something I always preface my opinion with "I am new so my information may not be accurate - you should check with your instructor." I am CERTAINLY not going to give advice on hook turns, flat turns, landing in general, canopy size, etc. . .this list could become quite long if I make it comprehensive. . .but if an AFF student says to me "how do you overcome door fear". . .I AM QUITE QUALIFIED to talk about that. If someone with 300 + jumps asks about canopy control. . .I am not going to answer. . .I am lucky if I get my canopy to the ground, how could I ever even THINK about giving this guy instruction or advice.

Yes, I do understand what your point was, and I have seen some without any experience whatsoever try to give advice on things they "heard on the board" but had no experience at, but your statement is blanket and needs to be clarified so that newbies are not intimidated about sharing their experiences. . .if we don't share, we don't get all the advice and support from those of you with much more experience than we have. And yes, any advice I receive on the board I ALWAYS run by my instructors first before putting it into play. . .

IMHO. . .
________________________________________
Take risks not to escape life… but to prevent life from escaping. ~ A bumper sticker at the DZ
FGF #6
Darcy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'm sure ChasingBlueSky wasn't intending a dig at anyone specific - we all know there are people ahead of the learning curve as well as those behind it. If you're ahead and can for example, spot when gear is fitted wrong, great! Keep ahead. If you're behind the learning curve, listen more than you talk... I guess all he was saying was "think before you talk"... nice idea... must try it sometime. ;)

Will

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I always preface my opinion with "I am new so my information may not be accurate - you should check with your instructor."



Good idea to say that, esp if you have never seen that person in the air...however, if you are on dz.com doing that - you can never make sure that jumper does go check. Are you responsible for that individual? No, but ask yourself - how would you feel reading an incident report that describes some of the advice you gave to that jumper?
Think it can't happen? I know people on this board that have spent time in the hospital quite broken because of poor advice given to them by someone they thought were experienced.


Quote


I am CERTAINLY not going to give advice on hook turns, flat turns, landing in general, canopy size, etc. . .this list could become quite long if I make it comprehensive. . .but if an AFF student says to me "how do you overcome door fear". . .I AM QUITE QUALIFIED to talk about that. If someone with 300 + jumps asks about canopy control. . .I am not going to answer. . .I am lucky if I get my canopy to the ground, how could I ever even THINK about giving this guy instruction or advice.



Talking about door fear, gear fear, how you discovered to relax so you stopped spinning - those are a bit different than what I was refereing to. Don't forget, I was a student as well - I do remember the fear and doubt.

Quote

but your statement is blanket and needs to be clarified so that newbies are not intimidated about sharing their experiences. . .if we don't share, we don't get all the advice and support from those of you with much more experience than we have.



Yes, it was a blanket statement. I did that on purpose - not to piss off low experienced jumpers, or to disregard their knowledge. I did it to make them think, nothing more, nothing less. It seems to be working.
_________________________________________
you can burn the land and boil the sea, but you can't take the sky from me....
I WILL fly again.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

No, but ask yourself - how would you feel reading an incident report that describes some of the advice you gave to that jumper?



question...i guess im being the deveils advocate..but say someone who is a newbie..doesnt give advice and then is responsible for an incident? and all he or she needed to do was say something but decided to hold their tounge because they didnt want to get their ass chewed out here

"Airborne all the way"
EL Cantador Rodriguez

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

No, but ask yourself - how would you feel reading an incident report that describes some of the advice you gave to that jumper?



question...i guess im being the deveils advocate..but say someone who is a newbie..doesnt give advice and then is responsible for an incident? and all he or she needed to do was say something but decided to hold their tounge because they didnt want to get their ass chewed out here



I'm not saying to keep your mouth shut - but to think first. If it honestly looks like someone is being stupid, and on the path to leave a crater,....then say it. Or better yet - as HappyThoughts said earlier - ask, treat with respect, and voice concern.
_________________________________________
you can burn the land and boil the sea, but you can't take the sky from me....
I WILL fly again.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

Quote

No, but ask yourself - how would you feel reading an incident report that describes some of the advice you gave to that jumper?



question...i guess im being the deveils advocate..but say someone who is a newbie..doesnt give advice and then is responsible for an incident? and all he or she needed to do was say something but decided to hold their tounge because they didnt want to get their ass chewed out here



I'm not saying to keep your mouth shut - but to think first. If it honestly looks like someone is being stupid, and on the path to leave a crater,....then say it. Or better yet - as HappyThoughts said earlier - ask, treat with respect, and voice concern.




ok...i agree with u 200% on that one! just making sure!

"Airborne all the way"
EL Cantador Rodriguez

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
question...i guess im being the deveils advocate..but say someone who is a newbie..doesnt give advice and then is responsible for an incident? and all he or she needed to do was say something but decided to hold their tounge because they didnt want to get their ass chewed out here



i don't think newbies like myself should keep our mouths shut. If i ever saw something that didn't look right to me i always asked a senior instructor and if it turned out to be something he would explain to me what was wrong or right about what i saw and act. If some one asked me a question and i didn't know i would say '' I don't know but if you thnk its going to affect your jump i will help you find the right person to talk to. and if i could answer i would make sure to ask if my answer is correct before i say anything to the jumper. if you want to flame me for being to cautious, then feel free to do so. I would rather have someone flame at me so i can understand why instead of having them say fuck off, you know nothing and walk away. i have read in these forumns about divers who have huge jump numbers and for some reason they foreget the small things that they need for the jump, like your rig, altimeter....... play safe but have fun


--------------------------------------------------
who Jah bless Let no man curse.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Forgetting the Altimeter is'nt a big deal.

Looking back at myself and my posts from a year ago, 2 years ago and before that even is humbling... things that I swore then I knew to be true I now know to be far far from the truth. Things that I heard and spoke like they were gospel then I know to be coming from false messiah's now. Even things I experienced then I look back and say how did I survive that knowing what I know now?

I'm going to make an effort from now on to keep my mouth shut more and listen more. Not only listen more... but listen from the right people. People like Ron, BillVon, Bill Booth, KellyF, Mjosparky... they have have things to teach if people are willing to listen. Part of listening is keeping your ears open and your mouth closed.
Yesterday is history
And tomorrow is a mystery

Parachutemanuals.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I'm talking arguing - not clarification. Michelle is grinding the axe on someone else's behalf here.


No, Michele is not. Please don't assume anything, Tonto.

I asked for clarification. I asked because I wanted to understand the parameters of CBS's question. I answered from my experience. I said nothing about wingsuit, camera, et cetera.

And the original question "if I see someone do something dangerous" indeed was about chest straps...not swooping. I know nothing about swooping. I do know about chest straps.

This is an interesting thread.

Ciels-
Michele


~Do Angels keep the dreams we seek
While our hearts lie bleeding?~

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Looking back at myself and my posts from a year ago, 2 years ago and before that even is humbling... things that I swore then I knew to be true I now know to be far far from the truth. Things that I heard and spoke like they were gospel then I know to be coming from false messiah's now. Even things I experienced then I look back and say how did I survive that knowing what I know now?

I'm going to make an effort from now on to keep my mouth shut more and listen more. Not only listen more... but listen from the right people. People like Ron, BillVon, Bill Booth, KellyF, Mjosparky... they have have things to teach if people are willing to listen. Part of listening is keeping your ears open and your mouth closed.



You and me both. The longer I've been in the sport and the more I learn, the more I really realize that I don't know very much. Its nice that on this site we have folks like Bill Booth, Ron, KellyF, Hooknswoop etc that are willing to give their educated opinions to help us out.
--"When I die, may I be surrounded by scattered chrome and burning gasoline."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote


I'm going to make an effort from now on to keep my mouth shut more and listen more. Not only listen more... but listen from the right people. People like Ron, BillVon, Bill Booth, KellyF, Mjosparky... they have have things to teach if people are willing to listen. Part of listening is keeping your ears open and your mouth closed.




wouldn't be wiser to ask someone you know has more expierence than you if you see something questionable or you don't see something? By approaching a senior instuctor or the S&TA to satisfy your mind. but if you get told that it is nothing to worry about and it is explained fully and completely and that the jumper in question is well aware of the situation then your answer is given without interuption to the diver in question. You then may be able to get enough nerve as a newbie or who ever to ask the jumper in question about what you saw then you have possibly prevented something from going wrong. I guess all i am saying is if i ask someone with more expierence a question and get brushed off then i choose not to get in the plane with that person until i feel right. cheers


--------------------------------------------------
who Jah bless Let no man curse.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Here's part of a thread that I argued with someone with much more experience than me in:
----------------------------------------------------------
Me " Hi, Chris. I understand your logic here. Just thought i'd point out that you could be losing valuable ground coverage while doing this. So, maybe you're unsure, and you decide to float in brakes. You still don't really know what you're doing for a while, and then you have no chance to make it back to the dz because you were downwind flying in brakes and now you are forced to find an alternate.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Chirs: I disagree, Angela. I believe that if flying in brakes up high while making your plans would prevent you from making it back to the DZ, then you needed to find an alternate landing area anyway

-----------------------------------------------------------

Well, lookee there. I thought I knew what I was talking about but after reading his logic a few times, I agree with the point he was making. I mean, who wants to count on just barely making it back, anyhow? That makes sense, if you're flying in brakes for a moment is going to affect your not making it back, then maybe you should be seeking an alternate landing area. Good point, I learned something.

So, maybe my arguements seem disrespectful to someone with more experience. But, you know what, this person did not get nasty about how I have no jumps and he is right because he does. He argued a point with respect and clarified what he was trying to say without putting me down for arguing with someone with more experience. Maybe I had no place to argue, but so what, I learned something, and maybe someone else had the same thoughts as me and learned something as well.

Personally, I am not going to give advice on hook turns, and shit like that. And, i'm not going to tell someone they will be 100% ok flying the same canopy as i'm flying, because I can't guarantee that. But, I have been playing with the accuracy trick and I felt I knew enough to respond there. I wasn't answering anyones question, I was arguing. I learn a great deal from debating points with people. I cannot simply read something and not understand it and accept it as correct when I don't think it is or have reason to believe that it is not based on what I already know. Debating greatly improves my own understanding of things time and time again, and I am not about to stop doing it because a few people think i'm unqualified to speak on this forum.

So, my opinion is that if it isn't going to kill someone, and I don't think that my argument was going to, then I think that arguing with those more experienced is ok. They are equiped with enough knowledge to retort.

Angela.



Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Remember, it goes both ways (this is pointed at no one in particular).

If you want respect, give respect. If a newbie wants the seasoned jumper to listen and respect their thoughts an opinions, the newbie should do the same.

Oh yea, somewhere in there you should try to have some fun as well.
_________________________________________
you can burn the land and boil the sea, but you can't take the sky from me....
I WILL fly again.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

I'm talking arguing - not clarification. Michelle is grinding the axe on someone else's behalf here.


No, Michele is not. Please don't assume anything, Tonto.



Hi Michelle,

Apologies for the assumption. :$

I didn't think the chest strap issue was an act - more of an omission. I guess like everything, too much info is better than too little, although hearing the same thing (Oh! Look! Tonto forgot his helmet!) every weekend since 1987 can get to be a bit much.

I still don't think safety should be a democracy though, where newbies just ask more and more people until they get the answer they want.

t
It's the year of the Pig.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I'm tired of people with under 1000 dives telling me I'm dangerous for doing something I've been doing for decades and thousands and thousands of jumps, like the "hook turns are dangerous! You should know better." speech from someone with 55 jumps, or the "CRW is for madmen. You could get wrapped - entangled! Die!" from someone with 1000's of dives who has never done CReW, but faithfully carries their little orange plastic Zak knife to cut their thumb open when they have a lineover.



It's my belief that you, as the person with more experience, have a responsibility to not get pissed off at stupid questions and speeches, but to correct. Someone tells you hook turns are dangerous? Agree with him and explain how you have tonnes of experience and can do them within a reasonable safety margin, something they can't do yet. Someone calls you crazy for doing CRW? Try to tell them some of your experiences at least, if it's worth it. That's my .02 anyway. I do the same with whuffos that say "skydiving is crazy!" Often they get interested enough to at least come and have a look.

There's also a personal anecdote I have that I feel would be interesting in this thread. When I bought my 160 Tri, I went through a downsizing process before jumping it, just like I learned on this board. I was jumping a 215 F111 canopy when an experienced jumper I respect told me that I would be fine jumping my 160, it would behave similarly because it's ZP. Now, the Tri is a CRW canopy, and it really doesn't have that much flare, at least that's what I feel after comparing it to the Safire2 and talking to people at the DZs around here. It's definitely not like the F111 canopies that you simply stab all the way down and they stop dead in their tracks. Suffice to say I crashed and got real dirty on that first jump with it, and many subsequent jumps.

Now I've flown a 149 Safire2. The people who watched me all said that my control of it was great, even people who constantly criticize me about my flight on the Triathlon. I'm still short of funds for it, so, since I still haven't bought it, people still give me advice. All too often I hear that I should go with a 139. Now, I weigh much more than I look, so this advice is often based on their perceived weight, not my actual weight. If I did not have this webpage, I would not know that I need to inform them of my real weight. I would have just listened and bought a 139. My wingloading on it would be almost 1.45. I do not feel ready for this, and I'm kind of attached to the bones in my legs, if you know what I mean.

Through this webpage I learned how to filter good advice from bad advice. The experienced people here are quick to pounce on the bad advice, so newbies learn to recognize it. And, as with everything, expertise shines through.

-- Toggle Whippin' Yahoo
Skydiving is easy. All you have to do is relax while plummetting at 120 mph from 10,000' with nothing but some nylon and webbing to save you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

0