0
firstime

RSL

Recommended Posts

I would call disconnecting something that will pull your reserve and leave you unable to disconnect the thing draggeing you a safety decision, I dont care about grass stains but being pulled into traffic, onto an active runway or into a fence can seriously hurt, I know to ground my main on landing but IF you start getting dragged you might not be able to stop, or even be able to pull your RSL before trying to cut away, even the time issue on the ground might cost you some nasty tire or propeller marks

Good Judgment comes from experience...a lot of experience comes from bad
judgment.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
the question is : would the reserve drag you away ?? I think NO. the only thing is you would certainly have to pay for a repack.

Why I would say NO ?? the wind is certainly not strong enough to :
-pull the reserve pilot chute strong enough to extract the reserve from the freebag, and if it is ..
-the reserve is packed nice and tight, would certainly not deploy.
moreover the spring is quite likely to jump towards the ground and therefore minimize the risks of deployment and inflation of the reserve.

once again I might have everything wrong... Please correct me if I'm writing nonsense.
scissors beat paper, paper beat rock, rock beat wingsuit - KarlM

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I would call disconnecting something that will pull your reserve



THIS "DRAGGING INTO THE PROP"-SCENARIO WILL NOT HAPPEN. WHEN YOU CUT AWAY AFTER LANDING YOUR PC COMES OUT, MAYBE THE BAG TOO - THERE IT STOPS!

(hey, my caps lock work!) :)

"Whoever in discussion adduces authority uses not intellect but memory." - Leonardo da Vinci
A thousand words...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I would call disconnecting something that will pull your reserve and leave you unable to disconnect the thing draggeing you a safety decision



Next time you need a reserve repack, ask your rigger if it's okay if you pull the handle outside (put a tarp or something down behind you to keep the p/c and freebag clean). Even if it's windy the reserve will not leave the freebag.

Disconnecting the RSL in a high wind situation merely saves you the cost of having the reserve container reclosed. The main will still go away from you if you cut it away with the RSL attached; the reserve pilot chute will deploy and may pull the freebag out of the container... but the reserve canopy won't be going anywhere.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

The main will still go away from you if you cut it away with the RSL attached; the reserve pilot chute will deploy and may pull the freebag out of the container...


just thinking about it now... If you have a skyhook ?? Would it end the same, admitting that the wind IS strong...
scissors beat paper, paper beat rock, rock beat wingsuit - KarlM

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Disconnecting the RSL in a high wind situation merely saves you the cost of having the reserve container reclosed.



ABSOLUTELY! ...Please listen to this people and once & for all dispell this common MYTH! Mere convenience or MINOR ($50-60 vs your LIFE) concerns should NEVER enter the mix of decision-making when it comes to safety reactions/EP's etc. in this arena.

Saying you will disconnect your RSL after deploying at say 3-grand because you think the winds may have picked up, because you think you MAY be "dragged" by your reserve if you on the ground after landing cut-away, is simply MIS-GUIDED, and INCORRECT. Like Lisa says, it is rather instead a minor inconvenience/cost item that when it comes right down to it, ...is it really worth it? If you are THAT concerned, simply do not jump an RSL in the 1st place.

Puh-Leeze people.... this "debate" is not new! ...Will some of you FINALLY begin to get even just a clue??? ---I, for one, am getting really tired of having to "pussy-foot" around this issue.

Bill, ...Maybe you want to try that "experiment" as outlined in other threads, similar to what you did with the 45' MYTH too?

As Derek used to say.... Please.... people.... "THINK"!

Blue Skies,
-Grant

Edited so as to be more "PC" ...and hopefully avoid being "censored" ;)
coitus non circum - Moab Stone

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
POSTED AND PM'D...

Quote

Huh, I wouldn't choose to jump without one, its there just in case I get knocked cold on exit or hit another diver in free fall etc..



Okay, fair enough. Try this one then out for size...

You are on the plane ride up to alt., now turning on jumprun and your buddy behind you says: "wanna pin-check"? ...You're very safety conscience, that's clear, so you say: "sure". So he opens your flaps, you feel him touching & looking around, then all of a sudden he says: "hey dude ...looks like you forgot to turn your Cypres on" ...it's OFF. ---What do you do?

I'd like to hear your HONEST answer to that.

P.S. ...not picking on you, and no, you have not particularly, or individually "ticked me off", so please do not worry there. That's the whole purpose of these boards sometimes ...to have some debates. Trust me, I will not "slam" you. Not my style. Besides it also serves NO PURPOSE. I will keep an open mind as to your response. So please, under the hypothetical situation as outlined above (which I HAVE seen, more than once in my experience BTW), what would YOU do?

Anyone else ...feel free to go ahead & jump in here and answer this one too. ...I will sit by the wayside, quietly here now for a while and "listen".

Blue Skies,
-Grant
coitus non circum - Moab Stone

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
>I would call disconnecting something that will pull your reserve and
> leave you unable to disconnect the thing draggeing you a safety decision . . .

If your RSL deploys your reserve, your reserve PC will fire and your freebag will fall out and lie in the grass. Unless the wind is strong enough to uproot nearby bushes, the drag of the PC will be insufficient to overcome the drag of the reserve against the ground, and your reserve will just sit there. Try it sometime you need a reserve repack.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
well I'll admit this .. you learn something new every day, I stand totally corrected (and dont know why this didn't occure to me I guess I just took the rumor at face value without thinking about it, for which I should be ashamed) .. I would however like an answer on the "what about if you had a skyhook" question

Good Judgment comes from experience...a lot of experience comes from bad
judgment.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
PM'd Back .. and now posted

As a part of my gear check before putting my rig on, and as part of my check before getting on the plane I make sure my cypress is on (as a student at skydive chicago it is required but I will keep this as part of my gear check) so being told it is off means 1 I really goofed my gear checks and maybe something else is screwed, or 2 my cypress is malfunctioning, I'm pretty sure that turning it on at altitude is no good (I'll have to check) but if I goofed something so basic on my check I cant trust the rest of my check/packing job, I'm riding the plane down. Now if I arrive at WFFC next summer and for some reason my in date cypress gives me an error code or dead bat, and a rigger says "hey I'll pull that have it back for you tommorow".. would I jump that day... honest answer at this experience level probably not, in another 150 jumps I'd probably jump that day but I'd want my cypress back asap, its a safety featue I choose to have, not a security blanket I can't sleep without.

Good Judgment comes from experience...a lot of experience comes from bad
judgment.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I'm pretty sure that turning it on at altitude is no good (I'll have to check)



You're right, it's no good. If the acft is climbing, the cypres will interpret the change in air pressure as an error in its pressure sensor, and won't turn on. If the acft is nice and level, and you do manage to turn it on, then you have set "ground" level at x thousand feet, so at x000 + 750', your reserve will (should) pop out. Probably a bad thing....



edit: clarified some stuff
--
Arching is overrated - Marlies

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

all of a sudden he says: "hey dude ...looks like you forgot to turn your Cypres on" ...it's OFF. ---What do you do?



"That's OK, mine is a cypres2 from that batch they were writing about at DZ.com - Airtec says I shouldn't worry!" :)
(Well at least it is still here - made a few jumps when even that wasn't the case...:P )

Quote

Anyone else ...feel free to go ahead & jump in here and answer this one too.



You'r not trying to start a DEBATE, are you?
:)

"Whoever in discussion adduces authority uses not intellect but memory." - Leonardo da Vinci
A thousand words...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

If you have a skyhook ?? Would it end the same, admitting that the wind IS strong...



Swiss precision? ;) (I hadn't thought of that...)

Never tried it (don't have a skyhook) but my guess is that the freebag will leave with the main and the reserve will come out of the freebag.
However: When there is enough wind during a FJC we always take a parachute out to fly it in front of the students ("come look underneath and see what a good one looks like, what closed endcells look like, et cetera") Even in winds so high that all jumping has stopped long ago we have to "unpack" the canopy - bring the slider down, put the nose up in the wind... When the slider is still up you don't see the parachute come off the ground.

The point is however: if you choose to jump with a skyhook / rsl combination (which COULD save you in a canopy collision close to the ground when all other options are gone) the risk of reserve deployment in high winds when you cut away after landing are not sufficient to justify disconnecting it IMO
(You don't want to be fumbling with the rsl when you are about to turn on final...)

Then again. tandemmasters disconnect their rsl routinely when the catchers are still in the hangar... :S

One "tandemmasterstrick" might safe the day, should you have to cut away on the ground with the skyhook / rsl combination: hold on to your steering toggles during the cut away so that the canopy collapses right there and the whole combination doesn't go far enough to get the reserve out of the bag.

You'll have a mess, but it wont drag you. :)
edit to clarify a bit:

When you hold on to both steering toggles while cutting away on the ground in high winds, you hold on to the back of your main canopy. It will make a flip and deflate. Another bit of good news: the risers with the guide rings will slide along the steering lines during that event - they will stop somewhere where your steering lines split in tree (or four). If an rsl + skyhook is connected to a riser, the combined lenght of half the reserve bridle + the lines of the reserve canopy is less than the lenght that riser will slide along your steering lines.

Sooo... I fail to see how the reserve could come out of its bag and inflate.


YMMV ;)

"Whoever in discussion adduces authority uses not intellect but memory." - Leonardo da Vinci
A thousand words...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

So he opens your flaps, you feel him touching & looking around, then all of a sudden he says: "hey dude ...looks like you forgot to turn your Cypres on" ...it's OFF. ---What do you do?



Say "OK. You're taking front float, right?", and make another kick-ass jump.

More than once I've notied at the end of the day that I'd forgotten to turn on my Cypres, I never really gave it a second thought.

-
Jim
"Like" - The modern day comma
Good bye, my friends. You are missed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

They are just logical extentions of reserves



No, they are additions to put in place to make up for poor saftey procedures.

Anyone can brain fart. But proper training, in my opinion, is better than all the cool saftey toys.

And the cool saftey toys can ADD problems. I am very current. (I have done 36 jumps so far this MTH)...So I feel better with my skill and training than cool devices.

As a student an RSL can be a good thing...And it is required anyway till you are licensed.

I would suggest that you kepp the RSL till after you have delt with a malfuntion properly.

IF you choose to jump with an RSL....I would not disconnect it after you open. And RSL works best when shit happens low.

And as for disconnecting it in high winds...I would rather just work harder to contain the main. If it is so windy that you will have problems controling the main after you land...Maybe you should not be jumping at all. If you have to chop it cause you might get drug...Its a serious situation...don't worry about the RSL opening the main..Its 40 bucks...And I have never seen a reserve open on the ground.

Quote

I also know its important to know your own gear and if I end up wraped



I bet that if you get into a wrap...The last thing you are going to remember to do is disconnect the RSL. I have had 6 malfunctions, one wrap, one wrap that cleared...I didn't have the presence of mind to think about disconnecting an RSL...I would have to bet that few would.

Quote

Huh, I wouldn't choose to jump without one, its there just in case I get knocked cold on exit or hit another diver in free fall etc..



VERY few Cypres fires are people getting knocked out...90% of them are people just plain fucking up...

I have one incase I fuck up...I could. I don't have one incase I get knocked out...Chances are that will nevr happen to me, but there is a chance I could fuck up.

People like to say they have them in case they get knocked out..These people either don't know the facts about CYPRES fires, or they just don't want to admit they have them in case they fuck up since its not cool to admit they could fuck up.

I have one in case I fuck up. I really doubt I will every get knocked out...There is a much larger chance I'll just fuck up.
"No free man shall ever be debarred the use of arms." -- Thomas Jefferson, Thomas Jefferson Papers, 334

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I fail to see how useing Back up safety devices would make me a worse skydiver, I KNOW a cypress is there only in extreems and most of the time is wasted space (much like car insurance) now I know more about the RSL .. so I'll keep it and not worry about disconnecting it before landing. But I'm still not gonna remove it from my gear. The problem I see is people are assuming that if you use back up gear/safety gear that gives you lisence to ignor training or do stupid stuff/skip the ground review when getting back current. I DON'T see it that way to me knowing my rig, researching the gear out there and picking what to add to make my chances of survival when I brain lock or the shit hits the fan better shows that I'm a smart skydiver doing this in such a manner that I can KEEP doing it.
Again a seat belt or air bag are not lisence to be a stupid inattentive driver. Wearing a helmet on a motorcycle is your choice to add safety, not to lisence you to be a dumbass. I don't know about the skydiving world yet (I'm too new) but if I saw two people on identical motorcycles and one was wearing a helmet and one was not I'd bet the helmeted rider was the safer/more skilled rider, not because he choose a helmet but rather the other way around the smarter more aware riders often choose to wear a helmet. Funney thing is for those riders who choose not to wear a helmet I don't see them giving the riders who do wear one a hard time. I've drifted off the thread here to try and get a point across. which is IF you see a diver doing stupid shit, or not going over safety procedures, get on him for it reguardless of what safety gear he has or lacks, and Never assume that just because I have some safety gear that you don't that in any way reflects less awareness or commitment to safety. You've got me in experience (that comment is to most everyone on this web page) which is why I ask you about gear, I want facts/experience, I'll take advice and opinions with that experience but I'm gonna evaluate that for myself and when I spot a logical basis for that opinion that don't fit me I'm gonna disagree with that opinion/position for that reason. I ADD safety gear like a RSL or Cypress, NOT substitute it for training/attention/pratice

Good Judgment comes from experience...a lot of experience comes from bad
judgment.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
>I fail to see how useing Back up safety devices would make me a worse skydiver . . .

It doesn't! Some people, however, do use safety devices to be more lax than they otherwise would be.

> The problem I see is people are assuming that if you use back up
> gear/safety gear that gives you lisence to ignor training or do stupid
> stuff/skip the ground review when getting back current.

And some people do _exactly_ that. "You sure you want to get on that jump?" "Hey, that's why I have a cypres!" So some people _do_ do stupid stuff because they have that backup.

How can you be sure you are not one of those people? That's very hard to say. You can't just say "I know I'm not." Wendy Faulkner, a very experienced skydiver and world record holder, became somewhat dependent on dytters without realizing it. Are you sure you didn't fall into the same trap?

One way of making sure that you are not dependent on any piece of safety gear is to plan to make a skydive without that piece of gear. If you have no problems doing so under ideal conditions, chances are you are not dependent on it. If you will never, ever, ever jump without a certain piece of safety gear, there is a chance you are overly dependent on that piece of gear.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I fail to see how useing Back up safety devices would make me a worse skydiver



Up until this thread you also thought that an RSL fired reserve on the ground would also cause the Reserve to inflate...You were wrong there.

You thought you would have the pressence of mind to disconnect the RSL durring a wrap...You were wrong there as well.

Before this thread you thought disconnecting an RSL after you had an open canopy was a good idea...Now you don't.

Ya think you could be wrong on this as well?

Quote

But I'm still not gonna remove it from my gear.



Did I TELL you to remove it? Nope. In fact I wrote:
Quote

As a student an RSL can be a good thing...And it is required anyway till you are licensed.

I would suggest that you keep the RSL till after you have delt with a malfuntion properly.




Quote

The problem I see is people are assuming that if you use back up gear/safety gear that gives you lisence to ignor training or do stupid stuff/skip the ground review when getting back current



And I see people do it all the time.

Quote

Again a seat belt or air bag are not lisence to be a stupid inattentive driver.



Studies have shown that drivers take more riskes when they feel "safe" due to having airbags.

It is a FACT that people jump with a CYPRES when they would not jump without one. You yourself said this.

Quote

but if I goofed something so basic on my check I cant trust the rest of my check/packing job, I'm riding the plane down. Now if I arrive at WFFC next summer and for some reason my in date cypress gives me an error code or dead bat, and a rigger says "hey I'll pull that have it back for you tommorow".. would I jump that day... honest answer at this experience level probably not,



So there is PROOF on that one.

It is also a fact that some people do jumps they would not do if they didn't have a CYPRES when they do.

I love this :
Quote

I'm not trying to tick anyone off I just say what I think (and it can be taken with a grain of salt as I'm a total NOVICE)



For a total NOVICE...you seem to have pretty strong opinions on what you think. And you ahve been show wrong what three times TODAY?

Quote

Never assume that just because I have some safety gear that you don't that in any way reflects less awareness or commitment to safety.



My point is you don't know what you don't know. You didn't know that a reserve is not going to just inflate...You do now. You thought disconnecting the RSL was a good idea under canopy...Now you don't. You thought you would be able to disconnect the RSL in wrap before you cutaway...Now I think you know you will not be able to do that.

You may be commited to saftey....But so am I. And As you have said I have the experience on you. I have seen people get lazy about saftey...I have seen people not train as hard cause they had cool toys...I have seen people do more dangerous things casue they feel "safe".

Quote

I'm gonna evaluate that for myself and when I spot a logical basis for that opinion that don't fit me I'm gonna disagree with that opinion/position for that reason



And so far we have shown you three things you were wrong about TODAY. 3 things in one DAY...Maybe you should understand we are not here to hurt you...In fact I hope you never get hurt. But the first step is to realize you don't know enough to have such strong opinions.

Quote

Good Judgment comes from experience...a lot of experience comes from bad
judgment.



And I would like you to learn from my bad judgment, and my experiences so you don't have to almost die three times.

But I mean what the hell do I know right?
"No free man shall ever be debarred the use of arms." -- Thomas Jefferson, Thomas Jefferson Papers, 334

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Up until this thread you also thought that an RSL fired reserve on the ground would also cause the Reserve to inflate...You were wrong there.


Acutally I was told it COULD

Quote

You thought you would have the pressence of mind to disconnect the RSL durring a wrap...You were wrong there as well.



Wrong? I've never been in a wrap how the hell would I know if I'd remember my RSL ..more importantly how the hell would you know if I would or not, if I intentionally made a crew dive I sure as hell would remember to disconnect it before the jump

Quote

Before this thread you thought disconnecting an RSL after you had an open canopy was a good idea...Now you don't.


Your implying I was in the "oh its open good, disconnect my RSL now at 2000+ ft camp" which I never said,

Quote

Ya think you could be wrong on this as well?


Its always possible that I could be wrong thats why the discussions are valuable

Quote

Quote

But I'm still not gonna remove it from my gear.



Did I TELL you to remove it? Nope. In fact I wrote:
***As a student an RSL can be a good thing...And it is required anyway till you are licensed.

I would suggest that you keep the RSL till after you have delt with a malfuntion properly.


Actually I wasnt replying to you in the "I'll keep it" statment.. now as to the Keep the RSL until you have delt with a malfunction properly.... why remove it after one properly delt with malfunction?.. thats like pulling your cypress because you remembered to pull on time or you got to silver before it did when you cut away


Quote

Quote

The problem I see is people are assuming that if you use back up gear/safety gear that gives you lisence to ignor training or do stupid stuff/skip the ground review when getting back current



And I see people do it all the time.


Then get on them about it but dont assume that because someone has safety gear that it makes them complacent.. . and don't assume becasue someone has chosen to remove (or not have) any specific piece of gear that it relflects grater skill/awareness on their part


Quote

It is a FACT that people jump with a CYPRES when they would not jump without one.


and that means nothing unless they are making riskier jumps with one because they have it, if so that is a mantality problem with that diver NOT with all cypress equiped divers, I choose not to drive without my seat belt, do you think that makes me a less safe drive then someone who decides not to wear one?

Quote

You yourself said this.

***but if I goofed something so basic on my check I cant trust the rest of my check/packing job, I'm riding the plane down. Now if I arrive at WFFC next summer and for some reason my in date cypress gives me an error code or dead bat, and a rigger says "hey I'll pull that have it back for you tommorow".. would I jump that day... honest answer at this experience level probably not,



So there is PROOF on that one.
If your gonna use my words against me at least acknowledge why I said them. My reason not to jump was because I would have to have SERIOUSLY GOOFED my gear check to miss turning on the cypress or it would have to be MALFUNCTIONING neither is a good condition to be jumping in!.. shit if on a pin check of your gear someone noticed you had misrouted your bridal and set yourself up for a pilot in tow, assuming it could be fixed on the plane with the door closed would you still jump or would that FUNDEMENTAL goof make you second guess the quality of your packjob/gear check?? Proof? at this level of knowledge I'd still be a STUDENT at WFFC I've got no buisness in air that crowded, probably jumping with other students.. the fact is I trust other skydivers but I KNOW shit happens so YEA I'll keep my cypress. But to take a short answer and twist it to mean I would make that jump with it and not without it.. I'll give you that one I wasn't clear what I should have said was AT THIS EXPERIENCE LEVEL I SHOULDN'T BE AT WFFC JUMPING I'll take that one my bad for misspeaking

Quote

It is also a fact that some people do jumps they would not do if they didn't have a CYPRES when they do.


Then that is a mantality problem with that diver a serious one if they aren't skilled enought to be making the riskier jump


Quote

I love this :


you know if you want to attack me personally thats what PMs are for save the sarcasm I'll be more inclined to listen to you if your not trying to talk down to me or twist my words to allow an attack, speak to the issue not the person argue my logic or point ESPECIALLY IF I'M WRONG

Quote

For a total NOVICE...you seem to have pretty strong opinions on what you think. And you ahve been show wrong what three times TODAY?


Yea I have strong opinions or more accurately I deliver my view/thoughts with aparent athority .. I come across as an Arogant F#@K I don't intend to but I know its a flaw, comes from being a military brat, and a skilled public speaker, (lousey writer though)

Quote

My point is you don't know what you don't know.


No one knows what they don't know

Quote

You didn't know that a reserve is not going to just inflate...You do now.


My mistake there was taking a more experienced divers word WITHOUT thinking about it as I've alread said a mistake I'll try not to repeat

Quote

You thought disconnecting the RSL was a good idea under canopy...Now you don't.


While I may have implied that (and If I was unclear I'm sorry but what I was getting at was close to ground maybe on base or so low where its not gonna make a diff anyway, I never said or even implied that I agreed with disconnecting it at altitude

Quote

You thought you would be able to disconnect the RSL in wrap before you cutaway...Now I think you know you will not be able to do that.


while I'm inclined to agree with you that its possible even likely I'd forget or be unable I wont agree that as a statment of fact I wouldn't remember this. You don't know how I deal with stress, when I note another diver close to me under canapy its one of the thoughts that runs through my mind so dont use this as one of your three points of "ha got ya"

Quote

I have seen people get lazy about saftey...I have seen people not train as hard cause they had cool toys...I have seen people do more dangerous things casue they feel "safe".


GOOD when you note this make it a point T THAT diver but don't use it as proof that anyone who wants safty gear is gonna use it as a substitue for caution and training, are you more lax with your main pack job just because you have a reserve?

Quote

Quote

I'm gonna evaluate that for myself and when I spot a logical basis for that opinion that don't fit me I'm gonna disagree with that opinion/position for that reason


I still stick with this if you have a problem with me thinking for myself feel free not to reply to me, or do so in a construtive non sarcastic manner I'd appericate it ESPECIALLY WHEN I'M WRONG

Quote

But the first step is to realize you don't know enough to have such strong opinions.


BS, in replies please attack my LOGIC or point out errors of deduction or knowledge so I can LEARN. everyone is allowed opinions mine come across strongly, thats just the way I am/the way I write/speak attacking me (or my opinions) by making false assumptions that I'm looking for gear to replace knowledge/training, being sarcastic and adversarial will only lead to long off thread responces like this.. I've got no problem admiting when I'm wrong and that I have a lot to learn. And you have me in experience which is why I ask, why I comment EVEN WHEN I MIGHT BE WRONG because I don't mind being corrected and some other divers out there might have been given the same wrong information or made the same wrong deductions I have and aren't the kind to post anything when they might be wrong. Constructive responces addressing errors of knowledge or deduction will encourage more posts from people, planed specifically constructed 3 point "ha ha see your wrong" attacks on someone's opinions will only discourage less bold posters who might spark good conversation with a posted mistake

oh sorry for the spelling/grammer errors I'm at work and in a hurry

Good Judgment comes from experience...a lot of experience comes from bad
judgment.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Acutally I was told it COULD



By WHO?
Quote

?? In high winds, disconnecting the RSL is a convenience only, not a safety issue.

http://www.dropzone.com/cgi-bin/forum/gforum.cgi?post=987756#987756



Quote

http://www.dropzone.com/cgi-bin/forum/gforum.cgi?post=987782#987782
the question is : would the reserve drag you away ?? I think NO. the only thing is you would certainly have to pay for a repack.

Why I would say NO ?? the wind is certainly not strong enough to :
-pull the reserve pilot chute strong enough to extract the reserve from the freebag, and if it is ..
-the reserve is packed nice and tight, would certainly not deploy.
moreover the spring is quite likely to jump towards the ground and therefore minimize the risks of deployment and inflation of the reserve.



Quote

http://www.dropzone.com/cgi-bin/forum/gforum.cgi?post=987824#987824
THIS "DRAGGING INTO THE PROP"-SCENARIO WILL NOT HAPPEN. WHEN YOU CUT AWAY AFTER LANDING YOUR PC COMES OUT, MAYBE THE BAG TOO - THERE IT STOPS!



Quote

http://www.dropzone.com/cgi-bin/forum/gforum.cgi?post=987842#987842
Next time you need a reserve repack, ask your rigger if it's okay if you pull the handle outside (put a tarp or something down behind you to keep the p/c and freebag clean). Even if it's windy the reserve will not leave the freebag.



Quote

http://www.dropzone.com/cgi-bin/forum/gforum.cgi?post=988066#988066

ABSOLUTELY! ...Please listen to this people and once & for all dispell this common MYTH! Mere convenience or MINOR ($50-60 vs your LIFE) concerns should NEVER enter the mix of decision-making when it comes to safety reactions/EP's etc. in this arena.

Saying you will disconnect your RSL after deploying at say 3-grand because you think the winds may have picked up, because you think you MAY be "dragged" by your reserve if you on the ground after landing cut-away, is simply MIS-GUIDED, and INCORRECT. Like Lisa says, it is rather instead a minor inconvenience/cost item that when it comes right down to it, ...is it really worth it? If you are THAT concerned, simply do not jump an RSL in the 1st place.



Quote

http://www.dropzone.com/cgi-bin/forum/gforum.cgi?post=988121#988121
If your RSL deploys your reserve, your reserve PC will fire and your freebag will fall out and lie in the grass. Unless the wind is strong enough to uproot nearby bushes, the drag of the PC will be insufficient to overcome the drag of the reserve against the ground, and your reserve will just sit there. Try it sometime you need a reserve repack.



Ok, Im not seeing ONE person tell that it would happen. And hell even you admited you were wrong.

Quote

well I'll admit this .. you learn something new every day, I stand totally corrected



Quote

Wrong? I've never been in a wrap how the hell would I know if I'd remember my RSL



You don't have a clue...And chances are you wiould not remember

Quote

more importantly how the hell would you know if I would or not


Cause people with shitloads more experience than you, or me, were not able to do it.

Quote

and if I end up wraped or landing in HIGH wind I know to disconnect my RSL before cutting away.



And again I bet you will not even think about the RSL. Better jumpers than you and me both have forgotten about it. What makes you so good you will remember?

Quote

now as to the Keep the RSL until you have delt with a malfunction properly.... why remove it after one properly delt with malfunction?.. thats like pulling your cypress because you remembered to pull on time or you got to silver before it did when you cut away



Nope the AAD will save you if you do NOTHING...The RSL will only save you if you do something but screw it up. After you have had a mal and handled it correctly...The chances of you screwing up your emergency procedures are GREATLY reduced. Until you have that first chop...Its a crap shoot if you will do it right.

Quote

Then get on them about it but dont assume that because someone has safety gear that it makes them complacent.. . and don't assume becasue someone has chosen to remove (or not have) any specific piece of gear that it relflects grater skill/awareness on their part



You have already show dependence on both Altimeters and AAD's in this one thread.

Quote

I for example am a newbie and wouldn't choose to jump without an altimeter

Huh, I wouldn't choose to jump without one

so while I choose not to jump without a cypress

but if I goofed something so basic on my check I cant trust the rest of my check/packing job, I'm riding the plane down

honest answer at this experience level probably not



So how are you NOT dependant on these devices?

This one I loved:
Quote


there is no jump that I would do without one that I would do with one



With 15 jumps you have no idea what you will do...And besides you have already said you will not jump without one (reference the above quotes)...So if you jump at all you are already breaking this little lie.

Quote

and that means nothing unless they are making riskier jumps with one because they have it, if so that is a mantality problem with that diver NOT with all cypress equiped divers, I choose not to drive without my seat belt, do you think that makes me a less safe drive then someone who decides not to wear one?



That whole statment is BS..you have already said you would not jump without one....So you are doing something more dangerous with one than you would without one by just jumping.

Quote

While I may have implied that (and If I was unclear I'm sorry but what I was getting at was close to ground maybe on base or so low where its not gonna make a diff anyway, I never said or even implied that I agreed with disconnecting it at altitude



So in high winds you are going to quite flying the canopy and try to disconnect it while on final??? Thats just stupid.

You claim to hate my attitude...But you have the same one...Damn that is funny.

The difference is that I don't have strong opinions on things I have little or no experience with. You do.

Attitudes like yours are the reason guys like me quit trying to help...or just quit the sport.
"No free man shall ever be debarred the use of arms." -- Thomas Jefferson, Thomas Jefferson Papers, 334

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[
Quote

reply]

Quote

Acutally I was told it COULD



By WHO?


BY MY FIST INSTRUCTOR YEARS AGO AT KAPOWSIN which is why I had the wrong information and posted it (thats what I get for taking information from someone at face value without thinking about it

Quote

And hell even you admited you were wrong.

***well I'll admit this .. you learn something new every day, I stand totally corrected


YEP I did as a concequence of posting without fear of being attacked for being wrong and I'm happily corrected




Quote

Nope the AAD will save you if you do NOTHING.


Sorry wrong an AAD MIGHT save you .. thats why its a BACK UP
Quote

Until you have that first chop...Its a crap shoot if you will do it right.


Um no unitl I have my first cut neither of us can say for certain, but its far from a crap shoot, this isnt random chance Its something I pratice OVER AND OVER AND OVER

Quote

So in high winds you are going to quite flying the canopy and try to disconnect it while on final??? Thats just stupid.


when did I ever say anything about final, and why should I "quit flying" to pull the disconect of my RSL? I pratice doing it without looking it might take me the whole of the base to get it but I'd never have to take my eyes off sweep mode, and never have to "quit flying" I can find all my handles including the RSL release with my eyes closed

Quote

You claim to hate my attitude...But you have the same one...Damn that is funny.


nope I never attacked you only defended myself, I never put thoughts in your head or words in your mouth

Quote

The difference is that I don't have strong opinions on things I have little or no experience with. You do.


BS you seem to know exactly what mistakes I'll make and what failings I'll have in emergencies without ever meeting me

Quote

Attitudes like yours are the reason guys like me quit trying to help...or just quit the sport.


your call I PMd you over this one and if you feel I've short changed this reply sorry but this is too long as it is and too off thread

Good Judgment comes from experience...a lot of experience comes from bad
judgment.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Um no unitl I have my first cut neither of us can say for certain, but its far from a crap shoot, this isnt random chance Its something I pratice OVER AND OVER AND OVER



And you will either do it right, or die. No amount of practice will make it 100% sure you will handle it right. I know several folks that did it wrong...Some lived...Some died. They ALL thought they could handle it and they ALL THOUGHT they practiced enough. NONE of them thought they were going to die.

Quote

when did I ever say anything about final, and why should I "quit flying" to pull the disconect of my RSL? I pratice doing it without looking it might take me the whole of the base to get it but I'd never have to take my eyes off sweep mode, and never have to "quit flying" I can find all my handles including the RSL release with my eyes closed



You said it right here:
Quote

While I may have implied that (and If I was unclear [bI'm sorry but what I was getting at was close to ground maybe on base or so low where its not gonna make a diff anyway, I never said or even implied that I agreed with disconnecting it at altitude



And while your hand is disconnecting the RSL, what are you useing to control the canopy? You have three hands? Ever dropped a toggle yet? Its killed people ya know. So if you have one hand out of the toggles...UH I hate to break it to you, but you have to quit flying the canopy to disconnect the RSL.

Quote

BS you seem to know exactly what mistakes I'll make and what failings I'll have in emergencies without ever meeting me



No, I know the mistakes that people have made over, and over, and over, and over...And they ALL THOUGHT they were better than the last guy that bounced.

I do know the failings that 20-30 jumpers make every year for the last 10 years.

I have had my fair share of mistakes...And I know what I was thinking durring those times. Not once was I cool enough to think "Hey, Im in a canopy wrap...I should disconnect that RSL before I cut away"...And further more I don't know ONE person that has ever done that...But I don know SEVERAL folks that have done the wrong thing in that same situation...Hell I almost did once. I almost cut away during a wrap. I was reaching for the handles when I stopped...I rode the mess in. Two riggers on the scene told me I would have died if I had cut away...The other canopy was wrapped around my container. My reserve would not have cleared it. Now I had 3 canopy wraps before that experience...And 1600 jumps. If I had 300 I would probably be dead right now.

So I have seen/expereinced/heard of/thought about/dreamed about/been yelled at for/been carted off to the hospital for/cried while my buddies have been put to rest...much more times than you can imagine right now.

And to behonest I would really you never have to do any of those things.

Pain hurts, losing friends sucks.

Someone wrote on here:
The problem with skydiving is...If you suck and keep jumping, you are gonna die. If you are good and keep jumping, you are gonna see a lot of friends die.

I'd rather people listen some and quit dying than quit.
"No free man shall ever be debarred the use of arms." -- Thomas Jefferson, Thomas Jefferson Papers, 334

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oops. ...I tried to warn you! ;)

See HERE

Jeremy (and others), There is no need to take what Ron is saying so personally. (or just the opposite, maybe you do, but...) If you can just shove some of that personal bravado/pride aside sometimes and listen to the CONTENT, you will find that oft times he does actually have something valuable to say. Like you say yourself Jeremy, and what I find it interesting you are also asking for some slack yourself now for, is the way your opinions come off so strong ...yet you want to attack or attack/defend back in the same way!

Unfortunately now as a result you just happen to be the one getting caught singled out & now in the middle of all this. Bowing out & simply "listening" at the point of (where you responded to Bill Von & myself with): Hmmmm.... "you can learn something new every day -I stand totally corrected" was perfectly appropriate, and held with it no shame at all. I have been "corrected" on these boards over my few years experience here myself many times! :):P

You did say:
Quote

I would call disconnecting something that will pull your reserve and leave you unable to disconnect the thing draggeing you a safety decision, I dont care about grass stains but being pulled into traffic, onto an active runway or into a fence can seriously hurt, I know to ground my main on landing but IF you start getting dragged you might not be able to stop, or even be able to pull your RSL before trying to cut away, even the time issue on the ground might cost you some nasty tire or propeller marks



And in that you were "wrong". Would Ron have instead saying it in the fashion that you were "Mistaken", were "incorrect" or had been "Mis-guided" have been gentler, or more "PC"? Perhaps.

The difference here though, and current point that Ron as I see it is now trying to get across to you, is that you are trying to enter into a "pissing match" now with him. ...And on the amount of "piss" (read: EXPERIENCE) that you have available in comparison to him?? ...Well, there quite simply is just no contest there.

I appreciate that you have attempted to ammend your misguided earlier asserted "points". I can even understand that. But you are getting "busted" on doing that now, and there really is no need for it. Learning is supposed to be good. There should be no shame or embarrassment over inexprience, or having been mistaken or misguided because of it. Please accept the learning experience instead (as you ALMOST did ;)) and put the "attitude" away.

Can that be said to/about Ron too? ...Perhaps, but I can also identify with his frustration. He just wants to keep you safe, and really wants you to LISTEN (which it does not seem like you are doing ...for whatever reason), that's all.

Consider it as being the bigger person if you want to. Whatever works for you. In the end analysis hopefully though all the posts, debate, and yes even differences of opinion (I had several with Bill Von earlier too ...remember? ---NO BIG DEAL) have given you something to consider, and constructively take away from all this!

Blue Skies,
-Grant
coitus non circum - Moab Stone

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I got it in my head from his (ron's) first reply that this was a slugging match and am too bull headed to back off, the sad part is I've re-read the posts and he really didn't come at me hard in the beginning. I had a stipid and now corrected reason to worry about high wind.. what gets me riled up is being told my Opionion is wrong, that my use of safety gear means I'm one of "them" those that use tech to replace skill and training. The problem is that 1 this is all preception and opinion so as much as I got into Ron for attacks on opinion I was doing the same.. I see a diff between choosing a cypress because it exists and being dependent on it, Ron aparently dosn't I hate my words being used against me especially when they are taken out of context in my reply I said I would ride the plane down with an OFF cypress, what I needed to make clear (thought I had) was that the cypress being off is the least of the reasons I woud ride the plane down, its part of my gear check to MAKE SURE its on I'm not gonna trust the rest of my prep if something so basic was goofed. Also having a malfunctioning cypress is far far far worse then not having one at all if I did turn it on and it was reading off on the same day something is up, I'd rather not findout the hard way just how bad the malfunction is.
To Ron: I'll take a breath next time before replying and I'll try to keep 1 on thread and 2 make my statments clear the first time.
TO FIRST TIME sorry your thread got hijacked

Edited to add (damn I cant spell for Ship)

Good Judgment comes from experience...a lot of experience comes from bad
judgment.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

0