0
riddler

Health care reform is now dead

Recommended Posts

Quote

And what are YOU giving back to society now? How important is your major to society? Are you going to be actually MAKING something or DOING something to help society... or just working in some IT field that makes new lil computer game that doesn't help the starving or clothe the naked



Had you read my posts in this thread, you would have a pretty good idea of the answer to your questions. Hint: It has nothing to do with IT.

Quote

You've made responsible decisions... but yet you expect others to pay for those that haven't



Nope. I expect those who have benefitted from society to give back to society. I also expect my income to increase substantially to include me in the group that does so much paying back.


Quote

Federal Income tax? Or just the sales tax on the ciggies?



All you're doing is highlighting your arrogance and ignorance. But, by all means, keep it up!

Quote

Ya know... It's nice that you feel smart enough to state your opinion as fact. You've had some book learning. You is learned in finance... and those of us dumb ones (like the lawyer and doctor) just can't recognize that YOUR OPINION is fact.



If you can set aside your overinflated ego long enough, try to consider the possibility that someone who studies financial and economic topics might have a better idea about such things than a doctor of medicine. You don't see me trying to explain to you how to give a Papanicolaou test, do you?

Quote

if this health reform takes place are you will to give up your jumping and or other activities you do?

So, are we to imply here that if the government gives out healthcare, than you would start jumping again (or it would at least remove one of the issues).



It would remove one of the barriers, yes. That doesn't mean I'm not responsible enough to wait until I can remove the other barriers.

Quote

Let me get this straight... it's not worth it for you to jump if YOU are responsible for your fuck ups, but if society has to take care of your decisions, then you're ok with doing it.



Well, you certainly don't have it straight. :S The implication is that I'm not going to jump again until I can be responsible for my potential fuck-ups, i.e. I want to have access to health care and enough disposable income to maintain a decent level of currency. Supporting universal health care doesn't mean I expect others to be responsible for me. It means that I recognize that our current health care system is broken, and private industry has failed to take the initiative to remedy the situation themselves.
Math tutoring available. Only $6! per hour! First lesson: Factorials!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Quote

It's also obvious that you have absolutely zero regard for me, deedy, Dr. Bordson, or anybody else who has struggled to get where we are, and find pleasure in the thought of actually inflicting pain upon us.



It's rather arrogant of you to imply that only those who are financially successful struggle. It also demonstrates a glaring disconnect with reality.



Where did you get that? Many of us of all socioeconomic backgrounds struggle financially.

Only ONE fucking socioeconomic background is in your sights.

I suggest congress tax students a flay rate of 50% per year. Receive $30k in student loans? $15k of it goes to social responsibility. In addition, students (because of their general good health) shall be exempt from coverage under this program.

Finally, college students are among the elite and owe more to this society than others.

This seems fair. And if you can't attend college because of it, then any fairness argument may be met with an argument that, "Congress has done it. Therefore, it is good."

Quit putting arguments forward that I haven't made. You are smarter than that (an addition 12% on the intelligent who are more able to figure out how to pay it).


My wife is hotter than your wife.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

If it's an impossible analysis then don't cite the outcome in your argument.



There is no reason to believe the outcome would be any different than the current comparison between Medicare and private insurance companies, in which Medicare operates more efficiently.

Quote

So any corporation that isn't publicly traded is non-profit?



Perhaps you should take the time to research exactly what a non-profit organization is.

Quote

By what measure?



To start, the Dow has just finished it's best two week improvement since 2000.

Quote

Quote

Quote

It may not have been intended to work magically overnight but that's sure as shit the way it was sold.



No, it wasn't, despite the claims you may currently be hearing from right wing pundits.



Really? Right wing pundits. Hmm.. didn't realize he was working for Fox now.



You clearly didn't read the article. There is no mention of a magical overnight recovery, as you claim.

Quote

So spending increases the debt and contributed to the recession. So, in order to end the recession, we spent more money. Then, before the recession ends, there are proposals to spend more money.



Do you really not understand the difference between borrowing and spending money on unnecessary wars and borrowing and investing money on national infrastructure?
Math tutoring available. Only $6! per hour! First lesson: Factorials!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

So how much more of my paycheck do you want to make YOUR reality a little easier?



I'm not getting any of your paycheck now, and I don't expect to get any of your paycheck later. Thanks for offering, though. ;)
Math tutoring available. Only $6! per hour! First lesson: Factorials!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

Only ONE fucking socioeconomic background is in your sights.



I don't have any socioeconomic class in my sights. Are you paranoid?

Quote

I suggest congress tax students a flay rate of 50% per year. Receive $30k in student loans? $15k of it goes to social responsibility.



Tax law isn't your specialty, I see. I'd also be interested in what authority you believe Congress could use for such a tax. Here's a hint: the sixteenth amendment doesn't apply.

Quote

This seems fair. And if you can't attend college because of it, then any fairness argument may be met with an argument that, "Congress has done it. Therefore, it is good."



Like I said, I would be interested in seeing what Constitutional provision would empower Congress to pass such a law.
Math tutoring available. Only $6! per hour! First lesson: Factorials!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

try to consider the possibility that someone who studies financial and economic topics might have a better idea about such things than a doctor of medicine.



Really? MD's neither killed off the health care system nor did the kill off Bear Stearns, AIG, etc. For the latter, it was 100% caused by those who studied financial and economic topics and were just good enough at it to bakrupt themselves.

Perhaps you would tell a judge that those who study political science are far more capable than they are at gauging the impact of laws. Or maybe one would ask a doctor about what is his or her daily experience?

Go take classes in Iberian Studies and tell a Spaniard that he doesn't know shit about the Basques. Such would be similar.

[Reply] You don't see me trying to explain to you how to give a Papanicolaou test, do you?



No. Stick to what you know. Dr. Bordson seems to have a good idea about how health care is provided and how her patients pay for it.



Quote

So, are we to imply here that if the government gives out healthcare, than you would start jumping again (or it would at least remove one of the issues).



Knock off the flippancy. You know exactly what she meant. If not, take a class in Conversation.

[Reply]It would remove one of the barriers, yes. That doesn't mean I'm not responsible enough to wait until I can remove the other barriers.



Why not?

Quote

Supporting universal health care doesn't mean I expect others to be responsible for me.



Therein lies the issue! I am responsible for myself and others. Others are neither responsible for themselves nor others. Hence, an unequal divide.


[Reply]It means that I recognize that our current health care system is broken, and private industry has failed to take the initiative to remedy the situation themselves.



Government is responsible for half of it. Private industry can't do shit.

So many think that they can do it better. Instead of starting their own company ~and prove themselves wrong and lose their money ~ they get the government to do it.

"Health care can be cheap, unrationed, and high quality. I know how." Nope.

Much like nobody has figured out how to turn lead into gold. So they turn to a business that is $10 trillion in the whole because it knows how to run things.


My wife is hotter than your wife.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I expect those who have benefitted from society to give back to society.

So because I went to school (at my own expense) and got a good education, worked hard, lived within my means without getting into debt and made some sound safe investments I should give some of that to YOU or anyone else in society......NOT!!!!

For the record, I do give back to society every day that I go to work. As a nurse I use the education that I paid for to take care of the sick and injured (society). When I am not at work I give back to society too. Every time I go to the store for food or anything else I am helping those who work there keep their jobs (society). Same for when I get gas, pay for my phone, electric etc.

I have to tell you, this entitlement generation that you live in is pathetic and will bring this country to its knees.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

For the latter, it was 100% caused by those who studied financial and economic topics and were just good enough at it to bakrupt themselves.



I would say that greed, deregulation, and dishonest executives played a MUCH larger role.

Quote

No. Stick to what you know.



LOL. You really don't understand what actuarial science is about, do you. This is far more of an actuarial topic than a topic for doctors and lawyers.

Quote

Knock off the flippancy. You know exactly what she meant. If not, take a class in Conversation.



There was nothing flippant about my reply. Knock off the arrogance.

[Reply]Why not?



Because, contrary to Libertarian belief, it is possible to hold liberal economic views and still believe in personal responsibility. Heck, my belief in personal responsibility is why I hold such liberal economic views.

Quote

Others are neither responsible for themselves nor others.



And there's the fallacy upon which your argument is built.

[Reply]Private industry can't do shit.



They won't do shit, anyway.

Quote

So many think that they can do it better. Instead of starting their own company ~and prove themselves wrong and lose their money ~ they get the government to do it.



You seem to have failed to consider that healthcare the healthcare industry is failing because of the private for-profit players.
Math tutoring available. Only $6! per hour! First lesson: Factorials!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

So because I went to school (at my own expense) and got a good education, worked hard, lived within my means without getting into debt and made some sound safe investments I should give some of that to YOU......NOT!!!!



I said nothing about giving anything to me. :S

Quote

For the record, I do give back to society every day that I go to work. As a nurse I use the education that I paid for to take care of the sick and injured (society). When I am not at work I give back to society too. Every time I go to the store for food or anything else I am helping those who work there keep their jobs (society). Same for when I get gas, pay for my phone, electric etc.



And when you pay your taxes, which was my point.
Math tutoring available. Only $6! per hour! First lesson: Factorials!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I said nothing about giving anything to me.

I corrected it.....YOU or anyone else in society.
Quote

And when you pay your taxes, which was my point.

And why should I have to pay higher taxes just because I achieved what I have? I don't have everything that I want in life but I have everything that I have worked for. If I want to help someone then I and I alone should be able to decide who and what that is since it is MY help!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I'm not getting any of your paycheck now, and I don't expect to get any of your paycheck later. Thanks for offering, though.





You want tax payer health care don't you? How much of my check do you need to make that happen?
If you find yourself in a fair fight, your tactics suck!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote



There is no reason to believe the outcome would be any different than the current comparison between Medicare and private insurance companies, in which Medicare operates more efficiently.



No reason, other than you have no numbers and no analysis. Saying tax increases will be offset by savings in healthcare is quite a claim. Not even the people pushing the bill are saying that. If you want to cite it in an argument then come up with something other than "well there's no reason to think otherwise."

Quote


Perhaps you should take the time to research exactly what a non-profit organization is.



You said non-profit means not for the profit of shareholders. Is that true or not?

Quote

Quote

By what measure?



To start, the Dow has just finished it's best two week improvement since 2000.



Well hot damn! That was worth $800,000,000,000 of taxpayer money, wasn't it!! Nevermind the unemployment rate...





Quote

Really? Right wing pundits. Hmm.. didn't realize he was working for Fox now.



You clearly didn't read the article. There is no mention of a magical overnight recovery, as you claim.



Fist off, I didn't say they promised a magical recovery. I said that's how it was sold. 'Doom and gloom if this doesn't pass before you read it!'

He said: "The time for talk is over, the time for action is now." ....."This recession might linger for years. Our economy will lose 5 million more jobs. Unemployment will approach double digits. Our nation will sink deeper into a crisis that, at some point, we may not be able to reverse," Obama wrote in the newspaper piece.

THE SKY IS FALLING THE SKY IS FALLING The only way we'll survive is with my stimulus!!


Do you really not understand the difference between borrowing and spending money on unnecessary wars and borrowing and investing money on national infrastructure?***

Do you really not understand that spending money we don't have is the same as spending money we don't have? What the fuck difference does it make where it goes? I've said over and over "There was a war" is :

A. Not a valid excuse for flushing trillions down the drain

B. Does absolutely nothing for promoting a valid solution to funding universal healthcare.



Supporters of universal healthcare can't even come up with a viable way to fund the system, much less put together a plan for implementation. I get so tired of hearing shit like "well people pay sales tax" and "there's a war in Iraq." So the fuck what? Come up with some semblance of a plan that addresses funding. Then we'll move on to other small issues like implementing and managing.

--------------------------------------------------
Stay positive and love your life.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites