0
Butters

Common Sense

Recommended Posts



I think it would be more accurate to say that the dregs of the once proud race of people have stayed on the reservation, with the vast majority of the more motivated, hard working (and often that means educated, because they worked for that) folks leaving the reservation for a better life elsewhere.

I saw some statistics a while back about the chance that someone born on a reservation who went to college would return to the reservation--it was something like 3%, and those were all either teachers or politicians/tribal leaders. Basically, the whole top of the bell curve bailed out because the reservation was such a pit.



I agree. Many with ambition, often seek a better life elsewhere, off the Reservation. Sometimes there is a guilt trip that goes along with that. Many say that if you really cared about your tribe, you'd stay and help your people.

Others leave to find a culture they don't fit into well. Can you imagine leaving family and friends, and then trying to fit into a culture that in many ways was different than you have known. It might be really tough. Many with grit, do leave the Reservation.

A Native American Friend of mine, grew up in the town I work in. He made the most of the programs that were available and went to college. He became a skydiver and made over a thousand jumps. Today he flies a jumbo jet to Japan and back. He's thinking of retiring and running for tribal chairman soon. I have a ton of respect for him.

I've been trying to get him to make a demo with me, and then talk to the kids....

The government had a relocation program at one time. I've talked to several native people who were sent to live in other parts of the U.S. Several were sent to L.A. Most came back to the Rez. I guess it was too much of a culture shock to remain in these new places. Can you imagine moving from the prairies of Montana to L.A.

The boarding schools were another collossal failure dreamt up by the federal government. I talk to people all the time who are still suffering from generational tauma as a direct result of that.

I wish the government would give more thought to the grand plans they come up with to help people....Many times it is tax payer money thrown away. In other cases it may even make the problem worse.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

All the native cultures in North and South America stem from very ancient Clovis hunter gatherers. They were true. Many people get confused by the definition of hunter gatherer. Paying to exist does not happen there either. They all take part in providing food, education, etc. It's an honor.



A whole lot of misconceptions in this post but I didn't want to copy & paste the whole thing.

First of all, the vast majority of native americans had abandoned the nomadic hunter-gatherer lifestyle many centuries before Europeans showed up. They were living off of farmed land and had permanent buildings, barns, silos, forts, etc. In fact when the Pilgrims arrived they were able to set up their village in an area that had already been cleared of forest by the Indians. The Indians had cut down the forest in that area years earlier to make room for farmland, but had recently abandoned that village due to a devastating smallpox epidemic.


Secondly, among hunter-gatherer societies, everything is not as la-dee-da as you make it out to be. Some hunter-gatherer societies are pretty peaceful, others are pretty violent. Others are in between. It varies.
Speed Racer
--------------------------------------------------

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

I believe we are too. It is depressing and sometimes I wish I didn't care so much. It is quite overwhelming at times. I believe our bodies are crying out (in the form of depression and psychological problems) to return to a more balanced relationship with nature. Or the "real world" as I call it. But instead people base their entire lives, and their families lives, on illusions such as money, time, religion, private property, death, materialism, etc. I think that we will be our own undoing. Remember of every species that has ever walked this planet, 6% went extinct do to a cataclysmic event of some kind. The other 94% died off because they were either A: Incapable of genetic adaptation or B: They were not in complete balance with an incredibly fragile planet. Look around. Anybody who thinks we are in balance with nature is insane. Literally insane. Well, we are all kind of insane as we are all in a "prison system". Our unbalance is so bad that we are affecting the balance of MILLIONS of other species. 200 species a day go extinct (real fact, look it up). That is 1000 times the natural rate. Anybody who wants to watch it, watch "What a way to go: Life at the end of empire. Pretty depressing but true. I do not think people will ever voluntarily give up the dangerous linear production/consumption cycle they have. They dont have too. In time the very finite, geobiochemical planet we live on will take care of the infestation. I hate to call my own species (including myself) but it's true. We need a change in consciousness. A paradigm shift. New programs wont fix it. Efficiency just increases production and consumption, evening out or worsening the situation. We can do our best to educate and promote awareness or just sit back and watch the world burn. Either way we're in for a wild ride.




>All that you said makes perfect sense to me. I wish I could put on some rose colored glasses and pretend that things aren't really this bad, but they are!

It's too bad that we are all so hung up on having more and more of everything (including kids).

I'm not saying I'm any better than anyone else. I'm a greedy bastard too. I just think that many people in America aren't as happy as they should be, and that many crave a simpler life, without all the gadgets, and material things that end up complicating your life.

Right now I have two big shops, packed full of crap that I probably don't even need. I own three houses and a fair amount of land. I should be really happy right. It seems like the more stuff I have the less time I have to do anything....It's crazy.

In the future I'm going to work hard to simplify my life. That involves getting rid of stuff I don't need, and living a simpler life.....closer to nature. Maybe that's not for everybody, but it makes sense to me...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Common sense is a misnomer. It implies a common understanding (as in everybody agrees) of what something is, or means, or does.
Personal sense would be a more accurate label; because what we refer to as common sense is really every individuals personal perception of the way the world is based on their life experiences.
For many simple things we do have general agreement about what is meant or what is going on - for example that the stars are humongous flaming balls of hydrogen. But some believe they are God's windows to the world. For someone that was raised with the later belief, the humongous flaming balls of hydrogen tidbit is definitely not common sense.
Racism is another touchy one where one person's common sense (or a whole group's common sense) is another person's pariah.
Bottom line is that common sense for every individual varies, as a result of, and is the distillation of, their lifetime accumulation of experience.
Experience leads to perceptions which create beliefs which generate behaviors which yield results that are our new experience . . . . .
We are all unique, just like everybody else.
" . . . the lust for power can be just as completely satisfied by suggesting people into loving their servitude as by flogging them and kicking them into obedience." -- Aldous Huxley

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

According to his argument, shouldn't we just let those people at the bottom just fall off the face of the Earth and not "help" them?



You can not fall off the bottom of the Earth any more than you can fall off the top, . . . I think.
" . . . the lust for power can be just as completely satisfied by suggesting people into loving their servitude as by flogging them and kicking them into obedience." -- Aldous Huxley

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

0