I'd like to hear the naysayers explain why this piece of shit shouldn't fry
By
birdlike, in Speakers Corner
Recommended Posts
mnealtx 0
QuoteThe fact that you look down your nose at plebs therefore says allot more about your feelings of class inferiority than it does anything about me in anyway shape or form dear boy.
How do you figure - YOU are the one that used the term, not him.
I love you, Shannon and Jim.
POPS 9708 , SCR 14706
Skyrad 0
Lucius Annaeus Seneca
Maybe this varies state to state (i'm no law expert), but isn't this typically how our courts system actually works with the death penalty? I mean I thought the jurors had to come to a unanimous decision whether the defendant deserves the death penalty. While I don't like the phrase "quality of the evidence" I suppose that could be one factor. I think their decisions are more based on the type of crime committed and whether they feel deep down that this person is undeniably guilty. The video presented in this case is evidence. Now it is probably good quality evidence, but it also shows the horror of what this person actually did. If they see that this is undeniably the guy and the defense had their chance to say why it might not be, as well as they see the terrible things he's done and they choose to go with the death penalty, then where does the "quality of evidence" statement actually contradict the way our legal system works.
Rather than "quality of evidence" I like that the punishment is more determined on the "type of evidence". I think that is a more accurate statement to what's being argued here.
Not to mention, didn't anybody catch the part where the creep PLEADED GUILTY. How does the "possibly innocent" argument even apply here?
Lets say someone broke into your house with a gun ready to kill you. I'm guessing you don't like guns so lets say you had a knife nearby. You are very talented martial artist that is fast enough to kill this person with a knife before they can shoot you. Would you kill the person knowing that if you didn't they would kill you.
I understand this is an entirely different scenario, but I'm going on the statement that many have made on here which is "nobody deserves to die". I know that not everything in life is black and white, but to say there are no black and whites is absurd. In fact your black and white would be that the death penalty is never ok. My black and white is that yes, certain circumstances call for it. There are certain crimes heinous enough to deserve the death penalty. Its not always about vengeance. I personally think forgiveness is divine and would try with every ounce of my being to forgive someone who killed a loved one of mine. Does that mean they still shouldn't pay the consequences of their actions?, absolutely not. Certain people have lost their right to live, and it is more beneficial to society to do away with them altogether. This is one of those cases. Whether it be a deterrant for others, vengeance for the family, justice, or insurance that he never does it to anybody again.
I think these people are a burden to the system and should not be supported by tax dollars in prison, unfortunately our justice system is flawed enough that is is more expensive to actually put the guy down, than to keep him alive.
QuoteAll death penalty supporters should be put into a death pool so they can be executioners just like jury duty. The consequences of that can be on THEIR minds for the rest of THEIR lives. You should have to declare your desire to kill your fellow Americans.
Just wanted to clarify that I don't think the majority of death-penalty proponents would consider the defendant in this case one of our "fellow Americans."
kallend 2,151
QuoteWith no disrespect towards you Amazon. I would like to ask a few questions?
Lets say someone broke into your house with a gun ready to kill you. I'm guessing you don't like guns so lets say you had a knife nearby. You are very talented martial artist that is fast enough to kill this person with a knife before they can shoot you. Would you kill the person knowing that if you didn't they would kill you.
.
Why should someone opposed to state sponsored killing in the name of "the people" necessarily dislike guns? I don't follow your logic.
The only sure way to survive a canopy collision is not to have one.
QuoteWhy should someone opposed to state sponsored killing in the name of "the people" necessarily dislike guns? I don't follow your logic.
Well, I could have probably left that part out.
Well, lets just say she has a gun then, given the same scenario.
Amazon 7
QuoteLets say someone broke into your house with a gun ready to kill you. I'm guessing you don't like guns so lets say you had a knife nearby. You are very talented martial artist that is fast enough to kill this person with a knife before they can shoot you. Would you kill the person knowing that if you didn't they would kill you.
You would be wrong... I would have NO Problem with ventilating them with my .44 Mag... I also have a CCW.
I made that decision a long time ago.. My life or theirs.... I think my life is worth more to me and I REFUSE to ever be a victim in my life. I will NOT be aiming to maim.. I will aiming for the kill.....period.
Dealing with the aftermath would be difficult.. but I am prepared for the consequences.
There is a VAST difference in defending my life under ANY circumstance than allowing my government to murder indiscriminately in my name... based on a system that all to often is not only fallible.. but is corrupt and morally bankrupt.
If more victims were armed under our current messed up system.. there would be far fewer victims.
I fully believe that an armed society is a more polite society.
normiss 898
Well said.
jcd11235 0
QuoteWith no disrespect towards you Amazon. I would like to ask a few questions?
… I'm guessing you don't like guns …
You don't come 'round these parts often, do you?



Having said that, an execution is premeditated, and should be compared to other premeditated killings if you are going to make comparisons.
I don't think you'll find too many folks are against killing in self defense, if the person honestly perceives their life to be in danger. Even the law usually treats second degree murder different from premeditated murder (as it should), since the former occurs in the heat of the moment.
* * * * *
One thing that I don't think has been mentioned in this thread is that the defendant will likely die more quickly with a life sentence than with the death penalty. Rumor has it, child molesters do not last very long in prison.
QuoteYou would be wrong... I would have NO Problem with ventilating them with my .44 Mag... I also have a CCW.
I made that decision a long time ago.. My life or theirs.... I think my life is worth more to me and I REFUSE to ever be a victim in my life. I will NOT be aiming to maim.. I will aiming for the kill.....period.
Dealing with the aftermath would be difficult.. but I am prepared for the consequences.
There is a VAST difference in defending my life under ANY circumstance than allowing my government to murder indiscriminately in my name... based on a system that all to often is not only fallible.. but is corrupt and morally bankrupt.
If more victims were armed under our current messed up system.. there would be far fewer victims.
I fully believe that an armed society is a more polite society.
Cool!

I know they are completely different scenarios and my only point in the matter was that sometimes we have to make decisions on when its ok to kill. We disagree on the whens, but not on the fact that sometimes its ok. I have a hard time understanding why it is so much more of a stretch to say someone is deserving of death after they commit the crime then before. The perp knows ahead of time that if they committ a heinous murder that their life will likely be taken for it if they are caught. I view it more as a broken rule = consequence, rather than bloodlust and vengeance. I believe it is a fitting punishment for the crime.
I'm sure the children this guy has killed wished they had a .44 mag handy.
QuoteYou don't come 'round these parts often, do you?
Well it has been a very long time, I don't know why I got the urge today to post again. I mainly opened this forum to see if there were any opinions on the Russia/Georgia conflict. I know we have some members on here from that area and I was curious what they had to say.
I don't know how, but I then got all tangled up in this thread.

kallend 2,151
QuoteQuoteYou don't come 'round these parts often, do you?
Well it has been a very long time, I don't know why I got the urge today to post again. I mainly opened this forum to see if there were any opinions on the Russia/Georgia conflict. I know we have some members on here from that area and I was curious what they had to say.
I don't know how, but I then got all tangled up in this thread.![]()
SC is an acquired taste. Like haggis.
The only sure way to survive a canopy collision is not to have one.
QuoteOne thing that I don't think has been mentioned in this thread is that the defendant will likely die more quickly with a life sentence than with the death penalty. Rumor has it, child molesters do not last very long in prison.
Since most executed prisoners make it 10-20 years before death, that doesn't seem to be doing the job.
A potential difference, I imagine, is that DP convicts are isolated from the rest of the prisoners.
birdlike 0
Imaginations on fire
birdlike 0
QuoteIt is truely shameful not to honour a bet. Pay the man.
Who the fuck asked you?
Imaginations on fire
birdlike 0
QuoteQuoteWith no disrespect towards you Amazon. I would like to ask a few questions?
… I'm guessing you don't like guns …
You don't come 'round these parts often, do you?
Having said that, an execution is premeditated, and should be compared to other premeditated killings if you are going to make comparisons.
Fine, let's.
Two sides are engaged in a war that side A started with an unprovoked attack (so side B is held harmless for starting the war).
A platoon of soldiers from side B is on patrol and discovers a platoon of side A soldiers encamped in the woods. They are not detected by side B and could confidently pass on by back to their base. But they are also under orders to take out any side A'ers they feel they can, if encountered. They PREMEDITATE a plan to wait until nightfall, and then descend upon and slaughter the side A'ers. They do so. They return and are recommended for medals.
Premeditated killing. Equivalent to murder?
Imaginations on fire
birdlike 0
QuoteBut it was he that took it to be derogatory to be a Plebian.
Once again, YOU were the one who used the term pejoratively, when you took umbrage that mere "plebs" would presume to put a number after their name. Clearly, you intended to convey that doing so was supposed to be the purview of the UPPER ("non-pleb" or "patrician") classes.
I really don't know who you think you are fooling.
Imaginations on fire
birdlike 0
QuoteNot to mention, didn't anybody catch the part where the creep PLEADED GUILTY. How does the "possibly innocent" argument even apply here?
It doesn't. It's just what they fall back on when they would look even stupider trying to make the "it makes us as bad as him" argument.

Imaginations on fire
birdlike 0
QuoteYou would be wrong... I would have NO Problem with ventilating them with my .44 Mag... I also have a CCW.
I made that decision a long time ago.. My life or theirs.... I think my life is worth more to me and I REFUSE to ever be a victim in my life. I will NOT be aiming to maim.. I will aiming for the kill.....period.
Dealing with the aftermath would be difficult.. but I am prepared for the consequences.
If more victims were armed under our current messed up system.. there would be far fewer victims.
I fully believe that an armed society is a more polite society.
We might have gotten along a lot better from the start if I had simply known this about you then.
Imaginations on fire
mnealtx 0
QuoteIf more victims were armed under our current messed up system.. there would be far fewer victims.
I fully believe that an armed society is a more polite society.
+ + +
I love you, Shannon and Jim.
POPS 9708 , SCR 14706
Lucius Annaeus Seneca
Share this post
Link to post
Share on other sites