Recommended Posts
mnealtx 0
QuoteSound like good ideas. Keep guns out of kids hands and punish people for not securing their weapons. Keep kids from getting accidently shot by cops who think their toy guns are real. Raise the age for semi-autos to 21 - good idea. We don't trust them to drink, so why trust them to use a gun?Regulate gun shows a bit more wisely.
None of this prevents good citizens from getting firearms.
Good job Dems.
Cool - maybe they can go after the First, next ... no free speech until you're 21!!
I love you, Shannon and Jim.
POPS 9708 , SCR 14706
Amazon 7
QuoteKeep kids from getting accidently shot by cops who think their toy guns are real.
That is a law that is being pushed by police departments... for exactly that reason.. and as friggin trigger happy as a hell of a lot of departments are these days its a hell of a good idea.. this whole shoot first attitude when they see something that looks like a gun... is all too real.
Zipp0 1
QuoteIf a child breaks in to your home and uses your tools to break into your firearms storage area, and commits a crime with it, do you want to be held responsible for the actions of a criminal?
Go back and read it again. It requires you to "recklessly disregard the risk" as written. If some child safecracker jimmies your lock, that is far from fitting those conditions. They do make gun safes that would be impossible for a child to get into, and probably thieves too.
--------------------------
Chuck Norris doesn't do push-ups, he pushes the Earth down.
Zipp0 1
QuoteQuoteSound like good ideas. Keep guns out of kids hands and punish people for not securing their weapons. Keep kids from getting accidently shot by cops who think their toy guns are real. Raise the age for semi-autos to 21 - good idea. We don't trust them to drink, so why trust them to use a gun?Regulate gun shows a bit more wisely.
None of this prevents good citizens from getting firearms.
Good job Dems.
Cool - maybe they can go after the First, next ... no free speech until you're 21!!
An 18 year old with a gun in his hand is equally dangerous as one with a beer in his hand. They can both kill, and require a certain level of maturity to handle responsibly.
I personally am for making the age 18 legal for BOTH. We need one standard for adulthood. But I'd also be willing to make 21 the ONE STANDARD for adulthood.
That would mean:
Military service only after 21. Drinking after 21. Voting after 21. Trial as adult only after 21, etc.
One standard.
--------------------------
Chuck Norris doesn't do push-ups, he pushes the Earth down.
mnealtx 0
QuoteAn 18 year old with a gun in his hand is equally dangerous as one with a beer in his hand. They can both kill, and require a certain level of maturity to handle responsibly.
So can a 21 year old...a 40 year old... a 60 year old.
Fact of the matter is, there's already laws on the books about all this crap... making it MORE illegal is going to change things? I don't think so.
QuoteI personally am for making the age 18 legal of BOTH. We need one standard for adulthood. But I'd also be willing to make 21 the ONE STANDARD for adulthood.
Currently, the only abitrary standard you've discussed that isn't 18 is drinking age.
I love you, Shannon and Jim.
POPS 9708 , SCR 14706
QuoteI personally am for making the age 18 legal for BOTH. We need one standard for adulthood. But I'd also be willing to make 21 the ONE STANDARD for adulthood.
That would mean:
Military service only after 21. Drinking after 21. Voting after 21. Trial as adult only after 21, etc.
One standard.
I absolutely agree. Be it 18 or 21, with responsibility should come privileges and vice versa. And no more of this bullshit of trying minors as adults. If we don't think the sentencing guidelines allow strict enough sentencing for minors convicted of particularly abhorrent crimes, we should change the sentencing standards rather than redefining the word adult on a case-by-case basis.
Blues,
Dave
(drink Mountain Dew)
Andy9o8 3
Quote
I personally am for making the age 18 legal for BOTH. We need one standard for adulthood. But I'd also be willing to make 21 the ONE STANDARD for adulthood.
That would mean:
Military service only after 21. Drinking after 21. Voting after 21. Trial as adult only after 21, etc.
One standard.
There is reasonable logic to having inconsistent 18 & 21 standards. Re: military service, average males are probably at their prime physical stamina and flexibility (note how I don't say strength) between 18 & 22. That's also the prime age range when 2-3 years' military service will have the least disruption in the lives of the largest sample of people. I agree with allowing 18 year olds to vote (especially if they're potentially subject to military service at that age; let them vote in or out the government that has the power to send them to war), and be subject to adult criminal liability at 18, too. Over time, I've come to support the rise of the drinking age from 18 (in those states where that existed) to an older age as a way of reducing drunk-driving accidents.
rehmwa 2
QuoteMilitary service only after 21. Drinking after 21. Voting after 21. Trial as adult only after 21, etc.
One standard.
from this list, which fit the bill?: sole gun ownership, speech, booze, smoking, drugs, abortion, driving unsupervised, working full time, voting, military service, keeping their babies, tried as adults, etc
and then, from that list, once you are an adult, don't expect the rest of us to pay for it
...
Driving is a one dimensional activity - a monkey can do it - being proud of your driving abilities is like being proud of being able to put on pants
Andy9o8 3
QuoteAnd no more of this bullshit of trying minors as adults.
Most people without criminal justice experience would be shocked at how many 15 - 17 year old criminal defendants get "certified as adults" for trial and sentencing. It's a hell of a lot.
Zipp0 1
QuoteQuoteAn 18 year old with a gun in his hand is equally dangerous as one with a beer in his hand. They can both kill, and require a certain level of maturity to handle responsibly.
So can a 21 year old...a 40 year old... a 60 year old.
Fact of the matter is, there's already laws on the books about all this crap... making it MORE illegal is going to change things? I don't think so.QuoteI personally am for making the age 18 legal of BOTH. We need one standard for adulthood. But I'd also be willing to make 21 the ONE STANDARD for adulthood.
Currently, the only abitrary standard you've discussed that isn't 18 is drinking age.
There are other issues. For example - college grants for 18 year olds. Whether or not the parents will help pay, parent income is considered on grant applications. Also, claims on taxes for dependency. Also, there are health care coverage issues. And the "trial as adult" issue. You are either an adult with all responsibilities and priveledges, or not.
One standard.
--------------------------
Chuck Norris doesn't do push-ups, he pushes the Earth down.
rehmwa 2
sole gun ownership,
speech,
booze,
smoking,
drugs,
abortion,
driving unsupervised,
working full time,
voting,
military service,
keeping their babies,
tried as adults,
independent assessment of finances for college aid
health care coverage under parent's policy
tax dependent status
...
Driving is a one dimensional activity - a monkey can do it - being proud of your driving abilities is like being proud of being able to put on pants
kallend 2,182
QuoteQuoteIf a child breaks in to your home and uses your tools to break into your firearms storage area, and commits a crime with it, do you want to be held responsible for the actions of a criminal?
Go back and read it again. It requires you to "recklessly disregard the risk" as written. If some child safecracker jimmies your lock, that is far from fitting those conditions. They do make gun safes that would be impossible for a child to get into, and probably thieves too.
Don't bother with FACTS!
The only sure way to survive a canopy collision is not to have one.
craddock 0
QuoteNone of this prevents good citizens from getting firearms.
20 year olds can not be good citizens?. I know 12 year olds that own semi's. My brother in law could kick most peoples ass in a round of sporting clays or trap at 12. His little shoulder would suffer if he had to do that with a pump.
mnealtx 0
QuoteQuoteNone of this prevents good citizens from getting firearms.
20 year olds can not be good citizens?. I know 12 year olds that own semi's. My brother in law could kick most peoples ass in a round of sporting clays or trap at 12. His little shoulder would suffer if he had to do that with a pump.
Your brother in law is NOT a good citizen of the collective and must be retrained... it's for the CHILLLLLLLllllllldrennnnn....
I love you, Shannon and Jim.
POPS 9708 , SCR 14706
SkyDekker 1,465
mnealtx 0
QuoteIf as a society you don't think your members are mature enough at 18 to drink one beer, why would that same 18 year old be mature enough to own a firearm?
Talk to Congress about it...they're the ones that passed the idiotic laws...I certainly don't agree with them!
I love you, Shannon and Jim.
POPS 9708 , SCR 14706
Butters 0
![[:/] [:/]](/uploads/emoticons/dry.png)
SkyDekker 1,465
QuoteTalk to Congress about it
Oh, I am sorry, I thought that american citizens voted for members of congress? I would think that if society had an issue with the drinking age, they would vote for people willing to change that.
Since that has never even remotely been on the horizon, I would have to assume that the american society does not think an 18 year old is mature enough to have a beer.
Hence, I still question why one would then think that that same 18 year old would be mature enough to own a firearm?
None of this prevents good citizens from getting firearms.
Good job Dems.
--------------------------
Chuck Norris doesn't do push-ups, he pushes the Earth down.
Share this post
Link to post
Share on other sites