Recommended Posts
Gawain 0
QuoteQuoteDid you know that kids won't be allowed freedom of speech or expression in those schools?
How so?
Students in France are no longer allowed to express their religion in school. Muslim women can not wear their head scarf, Jewish people cannot wear their cap (I can't remember what it is called), or a Star of David, Christians cannot wear a cross, etc.
Wonder if this kind of suppression is what helped to contribute to the feelings being improperly expressed by many rioters. Hmmm...
Just to prove I'm alive, and it's alright
'Cause tonight there's a way I'll make light of my treacherous life
Make light!
QuoteStudents in France are no longer allowed to express their religion in school. Muslim women can not wear their head scarf, Jewish people cannot wear their cap (I can't remember what it is called), or a Star of David, Christians cannot wear a cross, etc.
Very true. There are schools in LA where certain colors (associated with gangs) are banned. There are also schools in the US where a certain dress code is being enforced. I, for one, would not claim that such restrictions make freedom of speech and expression inexistant in US schools. Whether it is a good thing or not that such itens are restricted is another debate.
QuoteWonder if this kind of suppression is what helped to contribute to the feelings being improperly expressed by many rioters. Hmmm...
I doubt that the huge majority of rioters had any clear religious or political revendications. I think much like the rioting and looting in LA few years ago, it may have started as a spontanious movement (however violent and repressible it was), but degenerated into a free for all mob looting party with no clear agenda other than "doing what the others are doing".
"For once you have tasted Absinthe you will walk the earth with your eyes turned towards the gutter, for there you have been and there you will long to return."
rushmc 23

if we falter and lose our freedoms,
it will be because we destroyed ourselves."
Abraham Lincoln
Gawain 0
QuoteQuoteStudents in France are no longer allowed to express their religion in school. Muslim women can not wear their head scarf, Jewish people cannot wear their cap (I can't remember what it is called), or a Star of David, Christians cannot wear a cross, etc.
Very true. There are schools in LA where certain colors (associated with gangs) are banned. There are also schools in the US where a certain dress code is being enforced. I, for one, would not claim that such restrictions make freedom of speech and expression inexistant in US schools. Whether it is a good thing or not that such itens are restricted is another debate.
Valid point. However, there is a fundamental difference. Freedom of speech does not allow the open expression advocating violence or disturbance (like yelling "fire") in the US. Not being a gang member, I wouldn't know one gang expression from the next in an LA school. Also, the policies are not a federal law, unlike in France. Additionally, dress codes do not infringe on one's ability to express fundamental freedoms as guaranteed in our Constitution. (Other than that, I think dress codes can be silly)
QuoteQuoteWonder if this kind of suppression is what helped to contribute to the feelings being improperly expressed by many rioters. Hmmm...
I doubt that the huge majority of rioters had any clear religious or political revendications. I think much like the rioting and looting in LA few years ago, it may have started as a spontanious movement (however violent and repressible it was), but degenerated into a free for all mob looting party with no clear agenda other than "doing what the others are doing".
Actually, I think one can make certain comparisons on a social level. The difference is in terms of length of time, the similarities are in terms of the "have-nots" in a manner of speaking. It's no secret that these "minorities" (whatever their race, religion, economic status) get stepped on a lot.
Just to prove I'm alive, and it's alright
'Cause tonight there's a way I'll make light of my treacherous life
Make light!
QuoteAlso, the policies are not a federal law, unlike in France
France is not a federation, but a Republic, much like US individual states.
QuoteAdditionally, dress codes do not infringe on one's ability to express fundamental freedoms as guaranteed in our Constitution. (Other than that, I think dress codes can be silly)
Same in France. Not being able to wear a burqa or veil does not prevent one from expressing his/her religious believes. But I agree with the silliness of dress codes.
QuoteActually, I think one can make certain comparisons on a social level. The difference is in terms of length of time, the similarities are in terms of the "have-nots" in a manner of speaking. It's no secret that these "minorities" (whatever their race, religion, economic status) get stepped on a lot.
I totally agree. It is a sociological issue, not a religious one.
"For once you have tasted Absinthe you will walk the earth with your eyes turned towards the gutter, for there you have been and there you will long to return."
I heard the whoosh
Share this post
Link to post
Share on other sites