Recommended Posts
billvon 3,116
>cut-off our support for him?
Perhaps never funding him (or his parent organization) to begin with might have been a better choice. Even without hindsight, it's not hard to see how funding radical terrorists, and giving them billions in weapons, can come back and bite you on the ass.
Uh, John, I don't think that's what he was saying at all. I think he means we should never have supported him to begin with.Quoten Reply To
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please elaborate. What foreign policy change should America have made that would have dissuaded Muslim extremists from attacking America?
------------------------------------------------------------------------Quote
------------------------------------------------------------------------
For one thing John we could have not supported a terrorist group and it's leader OBL when it was convenient. We could have started there.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
That makes no sense at all.
So, you're saying that Osama only decided to attack us because we cut-off our support for him? Therefore, we should have continued to support someone who is a terrorist? And that's your idea of doing the right thing?
Of course, at the time (1980's) we weren't supporting him specifically, we AND the Arab group later to become "Al Quaeda" were both giving support to the Afghans to fight off the Soviets.
--------------------------------------------------
Darius11 12
QuoteQuotePlease elaborate. What foreign policy change should America have made that would have dissuaded Muslim extremists from attacking America? ***
For one thing John we could have not supported a terrorist group and it's leader OBL when it was convenient. We could have started there.
That makes no sense at all.
So, you're saying that Osama only decided to attack us because we cut-off our support for him? Therefore, we should have continued to support someone who is a terrorist? And that's your idea of doing the right thing?
It reminds me of history, where payments were made to Barbary pirates in order to have them leave shipping alone. That's blackmail. It's a lousy way to run a just world.
No John you are getting carried away thats not what i am saying. No one knows for sure what might or could have happened.
All I am saying is we should be very careful who we support. If we know someone is a bad person like OBL, or Sadam. We should not support them.
I don’t pretend to know what could or might happen.
What I do know is what did happen. I think it is very sad that we supported a group that is responsible for killing so many innocent people. We have done it more then once I think it’s time we stop and look at who we call our friends.
Darius11 12
QuoteQuoteI am the VP of sales for a million dollar company.
I came here 8 years ago with 1500 bucks in my pockets and no help from anyone I was 21 at the time.
If you really think that GWB would have been any thing with out daddy’s money and help you are in a dream world.
Did Daddy take all his classes for him at Harvard and earn him a prestigious college degree?
Did Daddy co-pilot that fighter jet for him and earn him his flight wings?
That doesn't sound like someone who is stupid, to me. Just because you made something of yourself, doesn't mean that Bush is stupid, or that his accomplishments weren't hard-earned on his own.
First that post was made as a response to rhino who asked what the hell do I do. So I told him.
That post was also made as a response that Bush is president so he must be smart.
I don’t think it takes great intelligence to have a rich daddy who has a lot of influence.
I am sure he would not be president if he were not born in to the family he was.
You can choose to deny that if you like.
crozby 0
QuoteWell, when evil happens, everyone clamors for the U.S. to "do something" as the world's superpower. And then when we do step in to help, everyone tells us to "butt out".
What evil are you talking about?
JohnRich 4
QuoteI think he means we should never have supported him to begin with. Of course, at the time (1980's) we weren't supporting him specifically, we AND the Arab group later to become "Al Quaeda" were both giving support to the Afghans to fight off the Soviets.
Bingo! It's odd that Darius didn't bother to mention that little fact. Given the choice at the time, it was a good move. We were trying to help them stay independent from Soviet domination, just as we are now trying to make them independent from Muslim extremism.
JohnRich 4
QuoteNo one knows for sure what might or could have happened.
All I am saying is we should be very careful who we support. If we know someone is a bad person like OBL, or Sadam. We should not support them.
So we should have let the Soviets take over the Middle East along with control of vast oil fields?
QuoteI don’t pretend to know what could or might happen.
What I do know is what did happen.
Yeah, it's so easy to criticize with 20-20 hindsight. But knowing what to do now ain't so easy.
So let's see how well you do at the "now" game: What would you do with the North Korea situation?
JohnRich 4
QuoteI don’t think it takes great intelligence to have a rich daddy who has a lot of influence.
That doesn't mean that people with rich Daddy's are stupid.
Do you have some kind of grudge against people with wealth?
QuoteI am sure he would not be president if he were not born in to the family he was.
The fickle finger of fate. There are millions of twists of fate in life that lead to someone becoming President. Change any one of them, and it could dash everything. One racist comment, or one blow job, can destroy you. A rich Daddy is no guarantee of success. Things like personal charisma, trust, and ideas, go a lot further.
Did Abe Lincoln have a rich Daddy?
Don't forget that the US sometimes uses aid as leverage to secure whats in the US's best interests.
It is not always about providing aid to "help"the people.
So I would maybe state " If I was King of America, I would cut off ALL foreign aid. Period. Unless it could be used to strengthen our position for whatever reason "
But other then that - I'm with you!
Most cases end up as damned if we do, damned if we don't.
Carpe Diem
Share this post
Link to post
Share on other sites