bert_man 0
sabre210 0
This is a genuine observation/question and not intended at all to be a dig at anyone, and I certainly don't mean to bait you guys or cause ill feeling. I have the utmost respect for you all.
I just want you to know that before you read further.
In some way, do you not feel that this is partially a case of reaping what you have sown. Continuum and it's sequel showcased the site as a 'playground' and in a way made it all look quite (for want of a better term) 'sanitized'.
With it's emphasis on trancey music and aerials and cool road trips, it unfortunately gives the impression in a way that Moab is a place you just have to go and 'DO' after throwing a bunch of gainers and flippy do's off the perrine. Even the fruit salad section, and some of the little asides from the top (everyone's doing front loops) give the general vibe that it's a fun ,casual place to go and jump and experiment and try shit out and make fun videos in daylight.
There just doesn't seem to be any underlying message that it's a place you have to have a healthy respect for. You don't really see people sweating it at the exit point (it's all smiles and jokes)....in fact the one thing you just don't get from it is a sense of fear or foreboding or just plain old scariness.
I think the music is the main culprit (this applies to all base videos i have seen) but also the edit process removes a lot of the pre jump jitters and preparations and nerves so that you're presented with just one successful jump after another. Just a succession of 'no big deals' set to some cool music.
Have you ever shown non jumpers or skydivers the final edit and seen them watch in awe but noticed they don't really get that pure 'gut' danger factor but seem to get more of a 'wow' factor. Play them the raw footage though and it's nearly always a different matter. They hear the wind and the birds and the pre jump nerves and the feet shuffling towards the edge and their response is usually more...respectful. They get it more....and so their response is more "i don't know how you can do that" and less "that's so cool, i'd love to do that"
Like i said, this isn't actually directed specifically at Continuum as most BASE videos on the market employ the same devices and techniques.
So i guess my point is, it doesn't really surprise me that newbies are turning up off their FJC's and not displaying the healthy respect they ought to. It comes as no great shock to me at all that 30 jump novices are trying out gainers off a 350ft cliff with only one previous aerial off the potato bridge and it wouldn't shock me to learn that people with a dozen jumps are weighing up going stowed and are oblivious to the added dangers they are exposing themselves to by doing so.
I love BASE videos as much as the next man - in fact i love em more than most - but they do tend to skew what for many is the reality of jumping and present it instead in a sanitized and palettable form which turns real danger into real cool, and really lucky into really gnarly, and really sick (as in stupid) into really sick (as in rad).
Maybe BASE has become a victim of it's own marketing success and maybe it might take the inevitable fatality and resultant up-roar over legal sites to get it back to where it should be, which is a past time not to be taken lightly and without appropriate respect.
Does any of this make any sense to you.
with utmost respect.
ian
www.adrenalineexploits.com
TomAiello 26
Quote...BASE videos...do tend to skew what for many is the reality of jumping and present it instead in a sanitized and palettable form which turns real danger into real cool...
I'm curious if you have seen The Ground is the Limit and what your opinions of that film were?
Tom@SnakeRiverBASE.com
SnakeRiverBASE.com
RayLosli 11
Another thing goes Right along with the Break Setting and Canopy Control is. I can not express this strong enough to people starting out. To be comfortable with is Getting Some Clearance Away from the Object when you Launch.
You defiantly need to be comfortable with taking a few steps @ a good pace/run and keeping a decent body position in FF. A cliff face is no place to go so head low it turns into your first front flip.
It does not matter if the Cliff is Over Hung. Just an extra 5 ft. of clearance could make all the difference in you being able to walk away.
.
clint 1
Then it's up to the FJC Instructor or Mentor or who ever is teaching you how to jump to tell you all about Moab and other Exit points you might be thinking of. IF they dont know, then they shouldn't be teaching the course!
-
Skydive Moab 435 259 JUMP
M.O.A.B. Mother Of All Boogies Sept 19 - 23, 2012
sabre210 0
Absolutely. Mentors and FJC's have a huge responsibility to explain some fundamental truths and suggest a sensible route of progression to their students, and although my experience of these courses is limited I believe that on the whole they do actually do this.
However, a student's exposure to this 'conservative' approach to base on their FJC is for a very short time scale and so it probably doesn't influence them as much as perhaps would be desirable.
I'm not suggesting that BASE DVD's are the source of all evil. They are not. I do think though that the prevailing vogue for showcasing 'COOL' over 'gritty reality' is having an effect on the expectations of newcomers to the sport (and i count myself amongst them). By snipping out the 'dull bits' and presenting 450 seemless, slick exits with technical aerials in 30minutes they distort what is actually quite a complex process; site evaluation, weather evaluation, ability evaluation, possible outcomes, outs, plan B's, landing patterns etc etc etc
Not wishing to labour (labor) the point, but one thing springs to mind which, for me anyway, illustrate the disparity between what we see on most DVD's/ BASE movies and the actual reality.
The first is quite simple. I've seen a fair chunk of footage of Jeb doing his thing and it has always impressed me. A few years ago in Norway i watched him prepare for one of his aerial spectaculars on the edge at Kjerag. I almost expected him to just stroll up and hop off i must admit, but the amount of time he took to prepare and visualise and go through his moves was truly quite an eye opener. Lots of eyes closed mental preparation, lots of check, double check, triple check his pc and pitch.
In the end i think people were almost tempted to go push him off cos it was taking so long. But that was a good thing. That was a slap of reality. A slice of the action that usually hits the proverbial cutting room floor cos it quite simply isn't cool. That was what people need to see to understand that to make these spectacular jumps look so good you need to practice and prepare and train and visualise.
This isn't coming across in many BASE movies and i feel that perhaps this is certainly a contributing factor in many low experience jumpers taking on jumps and sites which are far beyond their capabilities.
Tom i haven't seen the ground is the limit but have just placed an order for one. I look forward to seeing it.
ian
ps. Clint. With a name like yours you should have your own Private investigation firm. Brilliant.
Calvin19 0
see the message im replying to...
Continuum and C2 are documentaries. I doubt in any way they were meant to be instructional films.
...
...
-SPACE-
Calvin19 0
but your correct, there is a huge difference when i show my freinds raw footage and then something edited to weird trance music, in sequence. the respect is there for both occasions, but the raw footage gives them the reality,

Even hiking in utah can get you killed. Read about Michael Kelsey and his famed guidebooks. Utah is perhaps the most beautiful place on earth imho, but it is as dangerous as it is beautiful whether its hucking, hiking, riding or wheeling. It is rather easy to get hurt in the red stone land.
-- (N.DG) "If all else fails – at least try and look under control." --
pope 0
QuoteIn some way, do you not feel that this is partially a case of reaping what you have sown. Continuum and it's sequel showcased the site as a 'playground' and in a way made it all look quite (for want of a better term) 'sanitized'
I guess I didn't get my point across with the section on Jimmy P. in Continuum II. In it, he described in pretty good detail (with some pretty grim, non-trancey music in the background I might add) about how dangerous Moab is/can be, and pretty much supported what I was saying in my previous post with regards to jumpers coming to Moab with too little experience.
QuoteWith it's emphasis on trancey music and aerials and cool road trips, it unfortunately gives the impression in a way that Moab is a place you just have to go and 'DO' after throwing a bunch of gainers and flippy do's off the perrine. Even the fruit salad section, and some of the little asides from the top (everyone's doing front loops) give the general vibe that it's a fun ,casual place to go and jump and experiment and try shit out and make fun videos in daylight.
There just doesn't seem to be any underlying message that it's a place you have to have a healthy respect for. You don't really see people sweating it at the exit point (it's all smiles and jokes)....in fact the one thing you just don't get from it is a sense of fear or foreboding or just plain old scariness.
We made a concerted effort in Continuum II to keep the groms in check by making sure that it wasn't the happy-go-hucky kind of BASE movie that you describe above. And besides that, (and this goes for both Continuum AND Continuum II) I don't see what would give someone the impression that it is a place to "just have to go and DO" at all. I vaguely remember two scenes in the movie (C1) that showed a group of people carrying out an injured jumper, another hitting a tree... (BTW--if you want to see someone 'sweating it out' on the exit point, check out the Bridge Day 2004 and 2005 DVDs! Not Moab, I know, but good sweaties.
Anyhow, I know your post wasn't specifically aimed at the Continuum Series, but I just have a little bit of extra knowledge about these productions because I've seen them a couple of times. There are a shit ton of kick ass BASE videos on the market, and more coming out every month, and each of them shows a different view on BASE. My suggestion (not meant in a sarcastic or derogatory way at all) is to put a DVD on the market that shows BASE the way you see it, and present it as you think it needs to be presented, and see how it does... I for one would buy it to see your vision. And point taken on the "reap what you sow" comment, but I think it's an inevitable, and necessary part of the sport's evolution.
QuoteI think the music is the main culprit (this applies to all base videos i have seen)
I see where your coming from, and agree up to a certain degree, but this point could only be argued on a case-by-case basis, IMHO.
QuoteSo i guess my point is, it doesn't really surprise me that newbies are turning up off their FJC's and not displaying the healthy respect they ought to. It comes as no great shock to me at all that 30 jump novices are trying out gainers off a 350ft cliff with only one previous aerial off the potato bridge and it wouldn't shock me to learn that people with a dozen jumps are weighing up going stowed and are oblivious to the added dangers they are exposing themselves to by doing so.
Me neither, but I'd love it if BASE jumpers could stand together enough to get it into the over-ambitious grom's head that just because they survived their last jump doesn't mean they'll survive their next one. Stack the odds in your favor by making the right choices in learning, gear, and object choice (as a start), and you have a better chance of survival.
QuoteI love BASE videos as much as the next man - in fact i love em more than most - but they do tend to skew what for many is the reality of jumping and present it instead in a sanitized and palettable form which turns real danger into real cool, and really lucky into really gnarly, and really sick (as in stupid) into really sick (as in rad).
Welcome to the wonderful world of film/video. Isn't it cool??
Utmost respect back atcha Ian,
cheers,
pope
clint 1
"...The second time i got crabs...
SUPER TROOPERS!!
-
Skydive Moab 435 259 JUMP
M.O.A.B. Mother Of All Boogies Sept 19 - 23, 2012
Calvin19 0
in fact, a girl ACTUALY SAID THIS TO ME.
I rolled out of bed at 4am, i had to get some water i was laughing so hard.
But it is in sooper troopers. A wonderul Film

kleggo 145
QuoteJust out of curiosity, I would like to know what you think is a safe # of jumps to visit Moab.
I know jump #'s dont mean everything but my point is, more and more jumpers are coming to Moab with Very little experience.
__________________________________________________
perhaps in addition to a discussion re. # of jumps, we should consider a discussion of applying training / education / peer pressure to ALL of us to limit the incentive to do TARDS / gainers / flippy-do's in general at such "unforgiving sites" until your skills are rock solid.
is doing a solid 2 hand-held really such an unsatisfying way to enjoy the scenic splendor of Moab? (remember, when you step off the count starts at zero, not one
be safe
kleggo
manship 0
kleggo has comments I agree with.
I don't "think is a safe # of jumps to visit Moab."
Because there is no safe jump to be had there. I do think we are seeing a lot more ill-prepared people coming to jump, numbers achieved or not. Some ill advised jump procedures are also being followed there that are causing some problems -- some people are getting away with them and some aren't.
At Moab you got a 50-50 chance. 1. it all goes ok.
2. You have a problem.
Now you have another 50-50 chance. You fix the problem or you don't.
Fixing that problem requires awareness of the situation, not staring at the upcoming wall in amazement. Sometimes we can pull it out, sometimes we can't.
I don't mean any of this to demean any individual or group of jumpers, hell it could happen to me next time too, and I don't have a "safe number of jumps" to go to Moab.
Sorry for the ramble, I had a point to begin with. [More Jack Daniels Sir?]

t
I didn't invent skydiving, but I jumped with the guys who did.
The fast forward button on the remote!!

We see it on the reaktion on the peopels faces , doesnt matter if they are non-basers or inexpirienced jumpers that they didnt get it when something happening on the screen.
"ohhh, that was cool..." and frases like that...
they dont think about it...and when someone make a statment like Jimmy in C2 then they say "boring, give me the remote"...
most of them see only the entertainment and the cool pictures.
the viewer have no awareness for the danger and thinks "there i wanna go and do some Gainers like this guys"
its not the fault of the editor...and the funky miusic
its the fault of the Bridge-jumpers that think " an E is a BASE-jump like every other"...
"am I my brothers keeper?"...no

but everybody shoud start thinking and say:" I will not be the reason why the site i was jumping was closed because i fucked up"

tfelber 0
I think education is the only mechanism that will have a direct impact. Someone who has been taught and understands the inherent danger of jumping off a rock is much more prepared mentally to deal with the issue if and when it is staring them in the face.
I'm one of the low jump number people who fall into your discussion. I currently have 24 jumps(6 S's, 14 E's, 3 A's, and an O). Of the objects I've jumped I've only been off 4 more than once. Almost every jump has been a new object, and I'm still scared every time. That fear makes me more cautious and instills a desire to be better prepared.
As someone else mentioned, I don't think jump numbers are the best measure. I think there needs to be conversations between the people considering the jump and the people with more experience on the object. If the person still wants to jump they're going to jump, but at least the conversation was had. And it probably made a difference. That may be part of the problem, people don't feel the conversation will make a difference.
New jumpers don't just come to Moab, find an exit point, and jump. They talk to people about where the exit points are, how to access them, how high they are, etc. So there is an opportunity to have these conversations.
Telling someone "You don't have 50 jumps, you can't jump here!" isn't going to work anyway. After all this is still a very renegade sport!
clint 1
Telling someone "You don't have 50 jumps, you can't jump here!" isn't going to work anyway. After all this is still a very renegade sport!"
_________________________________________________
Don't call us when you get to Moab if you don't have the experience, we don't want to scrape you off the wall.
Perfect sinario, Fly to Salt Lake City, Go to TF for a few days to get current, drive to Moab, do your jumps, fly out of SLC.
Like I said, jump #'s dont' mean shit.
Your right, people just don't go to Moab, find a jump, hike to it, and jump off. What do they do.
They call Apex/Skydive Moab or Slickrock and say, we are here in Moab, we dont have an 'E' yet, we have 16 jumps. Can you take us to Tombstone and show us some other jumps?
We get this call all the time. What would you do?
It's easy to say, let's go but we also work for a living and can't play all the time. And jumpers always expect you to drop what your doing and come jump with them. Ok, I'll stop working for several hours, show you a jump, and then get back to work. In those hours of playing, we just lost $200 in revenue.
If people really want to make Moab a safe experience and want to know where some exit points are, hire Apex or Skydive Moab as a guide for the day. It's $200 a day. This includes, showing you 3 exit points that day and how to get up them. We'll explain everything about the jump. Not just some words from other jumpers saying, it's 400', 2 sec delay, nice landing area, you'll be fine. Can't miss the exit point.
-
Clint
Calvin19 0
-SPACE-
clint 1
What is your email address. or PM me.
Skydive Moab 435 259 JUMP
M.O.A.B. Mother Of All Boogies Sept 19 - 23, 2012
Calvin19 0
sounds like my first trip to moab...

actualy, word for word.
I do plan on going there again, probably next summer, but not before getting my own gear with properly tuned brake settings and doing a shitload of object avoidance drills at twin falls first, and just getting to know my gear inside and out. Any other new jumpers who want to go to moab would be doing themselves a huge favor by doing the same. And you'll feel much better at the exit point, too
Share this post
Link to post
Share on other sites